Whilst deposits of commercial importance are not very common, improved scientific methods and more careful search have shown that in traces the rare earths are of exceedingly wide distribution. Sir William Crookes has shown that yttria earths are often present in calcite and in coral; whilst Headden[4] noted that quite considerable amounts (up to 0·03 per cent.) were present in a yellow phosphorescent variety of calcite from Colorado. Similarly Humphreys[5] found that fluorspar usually contains traces of yttrium, whilst one or two phosphorescent varieties contain quantities varying up to 0·05 per cent. The presence of yttria elements in phosphorescent varieties of calcite is interesting, and some connection has been suggested; there is, however, no positive ground for the belief in such a relation. [4] _Amer. J. Sci._, 1906, [iv.], ~21~, 301. [5] _Astrophys. J._, 1904, ~20~, 266. More recently Eberhard[6] has found very considerable quantities of rare earths in cassiterite (tin dioxide, SnO₂) and wolframite [an iron manganese tungstate, (Fe,Mn)WO₄]. A specimen of wolframite from the Erzgebirge was found to contain nearly 0·4 per cent. of rare earths, over half of this quantity being scandium oxide. A process which is readily susceptible of commercial application has been worked out by R. J. Meyer,[7] for the extraction of scandia and the yttria earths from the mixed oxides left after the treatment of wolframite for tungstic acid. [6] _Sitzungsber. königl. Akad. Wiss. Berlin_, 1908, 851; 1910, 404. [7] Meyer, _Zeitsch. anorg. Chem._, 1908, ~60~, 134. Meyer und Winter, _ibid._, 1910, ~67~, 398. Using the spectroscopic method, which is capable of detecting one part of scandia in twenty thousand, Eberhard (_loc. cit._) has found that minute quantities of scandia and yttria earths are present in almost all the commoner rocks and minerals. The minerals richest in scandium were beryl, cassiterite, wolfram, the zircon minerals, and the titanates and columbates of the ceria and yttria oxides. These results are in agreement with the observations of Sir William Crookes,[8] who has made the study of scandium especially his own. From the fact that scandium was often observed unaccompanied by any other member of the rare earth group, Eberhard rather favours Urbain’s conclusion[9] that scandium may not be a member of the rare earth family. Spectroscopic examination has also shown the existence of some of the rare earth elements in the sun and stars (see Europium, p. 189). [8] _Phil. Trans._ 1910, A, ~210~, 359. [9] See under Scandium in Pt. II.