_American Criminology._ Tendencies in this country in the problems of
the treatment of the criminal have been overwhelmingly administrative
rather than analytical and academic. Our foreign guests in 1910 often
remarked that we characteristically experimented and did things rather
than debated and philosophized on the theories of criminology. The
extravagance of sole adhesion to the former method is increasingly
obvious, however, and has led, among other things, to the organization
of the American Institute of Criminal Law and Criminology, a central
body for the inculcation of more scientific methods for the treatment
of the delinquent as well as for the extension of our knowledge of
the criminal. A recent conference in New York City on the reform of
the criminal law and procedure indicated the wide-spread belief of
the ablest members of the bench and bar that our criminal law and
its administration need radical reforms. In the fields of criminal
statistics, also, we need far more light even if such light shall only
indicate clearly that comprehensive and accurate criminal statistics
are practically impossible to collate. To the efforts of the American
Institute of Criminal Law and Criminology to advance in accuracy, in
dignity, and in usefulness our store of information as to crime and its
treatment, the national conference should give full credit and strong
encouragement.
THE SUPPRESSION OF MORAL DEFECTIVES
Abstract of Address of Charles W. Eliot, President Emeritus of Harvard
University
The prevention of crime through the isolation or extirpation of
criminals offers many analogies to the prevention of disease by the
isolation or death of diseased persons. These analogies are obvious,
and are based on observed facts and not on any theory that all moral
defects originate in, or are caused by physical defects. Opinions
might differ widely concerning the bodily origin of drunkenness,
inordinate sexual passion, or kleptomania; and yet persons holding
different views on this point might agree as to the wisest treatment in
practice of such moral delinquents. Let us compare society’s treatment
of moral defectives with its best treatment of physical defectives.
In the first place, a large proportion of the crimes committed in
our country are not treated socially at all, the criminals escaping
detection and arrest, or being acquitted when brought to trial through
the ingenious use of legal technicalities and delays. This is as if
victims of scarlet fever or smallpox should be left quite free to
move about in the community so far as their condition permitted,
society manifesting no active interest in their welfare and taking no
precautions whatever against the spread of their disease.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account