The Roman Wall: A historical, topographical, and descriptive account of the barrier of the lower isthmus, extending from the Tyne to the Solway, deduced from numerous personal surveysBruce, J. Collingwood (John Collingwood)
History
The Roman Wall: A historical, topographical, and descriptive account of the barrier of the lower isthmus, extending from the Tyne to the Solway, deduced from numerous personal surveys
Bruce, J. Collingwood (John Collingwood)
Great Britain -- Antiquities, Roman; Walls, Roman -- Great Britain
But, after all, the works themselves furnish us with the best proof that
the whole is one design, and the production of one period. It is
difficult to conceive how any person can traverse the line of the
Barrier without coming to the conclusion, that all the works—Vallum,
Wall and fosse, turrets, castles, stations, and outposts—are but so many
parts of one great design, essential to each other, and unitedly
contributing to the security of a dangerous frontier. The Murus and the
Vallum throughout their whole course pursue tracks harmonizing with each
other; the Murus, however, selecting those acclivities from which an
attack from the north can be best repulsed—the Vallum, those from which
aggression from the south can be repelled. Stukeley was unable to resist
the evidence of his senses. Speaking of the works in the neighbourhood
of Carvoran, he says—
[Sidenote: STUKELEY’S TESTIMONY.]
I suppose this Wall built by Severus is generally set upon the same
track as Hadrian’s Wall or Vallum of earth was; for, no doubt, they
there chose the most proper ground; but there is a Vallum and ditch
all the way accompanying the Wall, and on the south side of it; and
likewise studiously choosing the southern declivity of the rising
ground. I observe, too, the Vallum (Wall?) is always to the north. It
is surprising that people should fancy this to be Hadrian’s Vallum; it
might possibly be Hadrian’s work, but may be called the line of
contravallation; for, in my judgment, the true intent, both of
Hadrian’s Vallum and Severus’s Wall, was, in effect, to make a camp
extending across the kingdom; consequently, was fortified both ways,
north and south: at present, the Wall was the north side of it; that
called Hadrian’s work, the south side of it; hence we may well suppose
all the ground of this long camp, comprehended between the Wall and
the southern rampire, was the property of the soldiers that guarded
the Wall.—_Iter Boreale_, p. 59.
Speaking of the works westward of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, he says—
The Vallum runs parallel to the Wall, but upon the declining ground
south, as the other north; this confirms me in my suspicion, that both
works were made at the same time, and by the same persons, and with
intent that this should be a counter-guard to the other, the whole
included space being military ground.—_Iter Boreale_, 66.
The reader needs scarcely to be reminded of the striking illustration of
these remarks which is furnished by the appearance of the works a little
to the west of Carrhill, and by the fact, that for nearly ten miles in
the middle of their course, the Vallum is commanded by the heights on
which the Wall stands.
[Sidenote: RELATIVE POSITION OF THE WORKS.]
Whenever the distance between the Wall and Vallum varies, it is
generally with some obvious design in view. Thus, as Hodgson, who
powerfully supports the view here taken, remarks—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account