The Room with the Little DoorMolineux, Roland Burnham
General
The Room with the Little Door
Molineux, Roland Burnham
Molineux, Roland Burnham; Prisoners -- New York (State) -- Biography; Prisons -- New York (State)
The law limits all opinion evidence. It is not considered as good as
testimony to fact; much has been written on the justice of so doing.
Judge Woodward in “The North American Review” for October, 1902, has
treated the subject from a legal standpoint. In this article referred to
he shows in no uncertain way how the opinions of experts in questions of
disputed handwriting are regarded by bench and bar, especially in the
higher courts. Moreover, he cites many instances of injustice done by
this kind of opinion evidence. Beside this, I believe, there is a justly
popular prejudice against this particular kind of expert testimony.
I have tried to show that this opinion evidence—expert testimony in
regard to questions of disputed handwritings—is less accurate and has
less authority than the opinion of other specialists. If this is true,
should it not be limited to a greater extent than all other kinds of
expert testimony? And to this end I venture to propose the following:
That a commission be appointed to thoroughly and exhaustively examine
all so-called public and official experts in handwriting. No thorough
and conscientious expert would object to being tested as to his
qualifications. Licenses should be issued to the successful candidates.
(Few “sheepskins” would be needed.) Such a license should be required
before the expert can practise in court.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_CHAPTER XVII_
_Prologue to a little Comedy
written in the Death-Chamber, and called_
ONCE IN A HUNDRED YEARS.
I come to tell you how the author sat
And looked upon the picture of his love.
He spoke to her—you know he could do that—
And she replied. But this you must believe.
Although no ears received her charming words,
Nor keenest eyes saw her sweet lips pronounce—
It was her heart which spoke to his and said
What none but they may know. ’Twas thus she brought him
Of love and faith and joy and merriment.
The last alone he has set down because
No tongue or pen can tell the other three.
But they, God bless them, knew it in their souls,
And so do I—for, would you think it,
I’m that happy man. Is there another
Half so blessed—“Once in a Hundred Years?”
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_CHAPTER XVIII_
_Impressions—The Last Night and the Next Morning—The Last Night_
There are unwritten laws and canons for all important occurrences in the
Death-Chamber. I do not mean the prison rules; but the way “we” have of
doing things. For instance, the new arrival, after he has passed through
all formalities at the officials’ hands, and they are many, is initiated
by “us” on the first night passed in our society.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account