The Southern Case for School SegregationKilpatrick, James Jackson
History
The Southern Case for School Segregation
Kilpatrick, James Jackson
African Americans -- Segregation; Segregation -- Southern States
Now, a widespread custom among Negro apologists is to scoff these
figures away. It is said, for one thing, that there is “a relatively
greater understatement of illegitimacy in the white group than in
the nonwhite.” For my own part, I doubt this exceedingly. It is
said, also, that a greater percentage of extramarital pregnancies
are aborted among white girls than among Negro girls. Perhaps. A
third line of rationalization typically has been advanced by the
_Norfolk Journal and Guide_, a Negro newspaper; this has to do with
the fact that slaves were not permitted to marry prior to 1865,
though they were encouraged to cohabit, and “it is foolish to
suppose that a suppressed and constantly vilified minority group
could wholly recover from the practice in a few generations.” A
related argument, if it is an argument at all, is that in pre-War
times “many white slave-owners promiscuously exploited their slave
women sexually.” Other rationalizations put some of the blame for
Negro sexual looseness on housing, economic opportunity, low income
levels, and the like. Generally, it is all charged to the “system of
segregation,” a charge that tends to collapse when it is observed
that the high rates of Negro illegitimacy recorded in the South are
not materially different in the integrated climes of Pennsylvania,
Minnesota, Illinois, Missouri, and West Virginia.
But the basic validity of the statistics is not entirely discounted,
even by Negro commentators. Carl Rowan, the Minneapolis newspaperman
who came to the State Department with the New Frontier, faced up
to them (after a good deal of preliminary squirming) in _Harper’s_
in 1961. A leading Negro educator, President Thomas H. Henderson
of Virginia Union University, offered some thoughtful comments in
a paper delivered before the Virginia Conference of Social Work in
1957. He said:
“Let me begin by saying what the problem of a high illegitimacy
rate among Negroes is not. It is not, first of all, a statistical
illusion.... [T]he illegitimacy rate for Virginia Negroes has been
ten times as high as that for whites each year for several decades.
After subducting the maximum influence of all possible sources
of error in the statistics, the consistency and magnitude of the
differential leaves no doubt that a real and disturbing difference
exists.”
The problem cannot be blamed, said Dr. Henderson, on any particular
desire to obtain public benefits under the program of Aid to
Dependent Children. Moreover, “it is not to any great degree a
problem of racial interbreeding--every indication points to a steady
decrease in interbreeding since before the dawn of this century.”
The problem is “overwhelmingly a problem of illegitimacy with both
parents colored.” He added:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account