The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836 — John Shaqi
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836Various
General
The Southern Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 8, July, 1836
Various
American literature -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Lastly, teachers are often enemies to the public in so many
particulars that I scarcely know with which to begin; not that I mean
to charge them with being intentionally so—for it frequently happens
with the best people in the world, that they are among the last to see
their own greatest defects. Some of the faults of teachers may be
considered as belonging exclusively to themselves, and for which they
can find no excuse whatever in the faults of others—such, for example,
as the two first enumerated. But those which I have now to expose, are
so intimately blended with the faults of their employers, of their
children, and of that portion of the world with which they are more
immediately connected, that, like the reciprocating action of the
various parts of certain mechanical contrivances, these faults must be
viewed as causing each other. Thus, the parental fault of blindness to
their children's defects, both natural and moral, and their consequent
injustice to the instructers who ever blame or punish them, give birth
to the equally fatal fault in teachers of carefully avoiding every
hint of incapacity, and studiously concealing the ill-conduct of their
pupils, because well aware that they probably will not be believed. If
compelled to make communications on so perilous and ungrateful a
subject, they are so softened and frittered away, as to produce a far
less pardonable deception than entire silence, since a sensible parent
would ascribe the last to its proper motive, when the glossing and
varnishing process might lead them entirely astray. The same knowledge
of the self-delusion, and consequent injustice of parents, leads
teachers to the frequent commission of another fault, in which they
often engage their particular friends as participators. At their
public examinations (where they have any) they contrive a sort of
Procrustes' bed, which all their pupils are made to fit, but rather by
the {478} stretching than by the lopping process. This is usually
managed so adroitly, that the public will see numerous goodly
advertisements, with many imposing signatures, taking their rounds
through all the newspapers, by which it clearly appears that every
scholar in the school, however numerous they may be, even to the
youngest child, performed to the entire satisfaction and admiration of
all who saw or heard them. It is utterly impossible that these
examinations, if fairly made, could have any such uniform and
favorable result; for the difference of natural capacity alone must
inevitably produce a great inequality of performance in the pupils.
Every body with five grains of experience, knows that many other
causes are constantly operating to increase this inequality. Such
reports, therefore, of examinations, fail entirely with the
reflecting, well-informed part of the community, to produce any thing
but ridicule, disgust, or pity, while the ignorant and inexperienced
are most unjustifiably imposed upon.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account