The Status of the Jews in Egypt: The Fifth Arthur Davis Memorial Lecture — John Shaqi
The Status of the Jews in Egypt: The Fifth Arthur Davis Memorial LecturePetrie, W. M. Flinders (William Matthew Flinders)
History
The Status of the Jews in Egypt: The Fifth Arthur Davis Memorial Lecture
Petrie, W. M. Flinders (William Matthew Flinders)
Jews -- Egypt
Thus it appears that the status of the Jewish colonies in Egypt was
at least equal to that of any other foreigners, and that they had
assimilated native custom and law. The ideas of these settlers at
the Cataract, and probably of those elsewhere, were derived from the
habits of thought of the monarchy, quite apart from the Babylonian
particularism. There was no objection to taking an oath by the goddess of
the Cataract, for a legal declaration, like any Egyptian. This is akin
to the later Egyptian Judaism, which sought reconciliation with Gentile
principles, as in the Alexandrian school of Philo, and was entirely
opposed to the bitterly anti-Gentile school which was developed in the
Captivity.
It is evident that there was no hesitation in establishing temple worship
at the Cataract, and probably also in the other cities that “called
on the name of Yahveh,” as a substitute for the destroyed temple of
Jerusalem. This is in accord with the establishing of the temple by
Oniah some three centuries later. There was not yet the dogma that no
temple could be legitimate outside of Jerusalem: that view seems to
have been a development of the Babylonian party, probably in connection
with their rebuilding of the temple at Jerusalem on the Return from
Captivity. A rival temple would probably have been illegitimate at any
time; but if the temple of Jerusalem was destroyed, or in the heretical
hands of the Hellenic party, then it was looked on as more important
to maintain the worship, rather than to abandon it because its true
centre was unattainable. This was in accord with Western Judaism, which
would subordinate the letter of the law to keeping the spirit of it; in
contrast to Babylonian Judaism, which by concentrating on the letter of
the law forgot the more important value of it, and thus “tithed mint,
anise and cummin, and omitted the weightier matters of the law.”
That the settlement at the Cataract was not very exceptional is shown not
only by the reference to a Jewish resident of Abydos[20]—purely a centre
of Egyptian religion—but also by a discovery this year of a rock tomb
of early date which had been re-used about the fifth century B.C.[21]
and inscribed with long documents in Aramaic, equal to over fifty feet
of writing. M. Giron came to examine them, but they are so far damaged
that it would need a longer study than he could spare to transcribe them.
It is to be hoped that some other Aramaic scholar will undertake the
work. This tomb is a few miles back in the eastern desert, opposite to
Oxyrhynkhos. It proves that in this region of Middle Egypt there was also
a Jewish settlement commonly using Aramaic.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account