"Dr. Robison, in the article Steam Engine, after passing an encomium upon me, dictated by the partiality of friendship, qualifies me as the '_pupil_ and intimate friend of Dr. Black,'—a description which not being there accompanied with any inference, did not particularly strike me at the time of its first perusal. He afterwards, in the dedication to me of his edition of Dr. Black's lectures upon chemistry, goes the length of supposing me to have professed to owe my improvements upon the steam engine to the instructions and information I had received from that gentleman, which certainly was a misapprehension; as, though I have always felt and acknowledged my obligations to him for the information I had received from his conversation, and particularly for the knowledge of the doctrine of latent heat, I never did nor _could_ consider my improvements as originating in those communications. He is also mistaken in his assertion (p. 8. of the preface to the above work), that 'I had attended two courses [Pg094] of the doctor's lectures;' for, unfortunately for me, the necessary avocations of my business prevented me from attending his or any other lectures at college; and as Dr. Robison was himself absent from Scotland for four years at the period referred to, he must have been misled by erroneous information. In p. 184. of the lectures, Dr. Black says, 'I have the pleasure of thinking that the knowledge we have acquired concerning the nature of elastic vapours, in consequence of my fortunate observation of what happens in its formation and condensation, has contributed in no inconsiderable degree to the public good by _suggesting_ to my friend Mr. Watt of Birmingham, then of Glasgow, his improvement on this useful engine' (meaning the steam engine of which he is then speaking). There can be no doubt from what follows in his description of the engine, and from the very honourable mention which he has made of me in various parts of his lectures, that he did not mean to lessen any merit that might attach to me as an inventor; but, on the contrary, he was always disposed to give me fully as much praise as I deserved.