Granting that the Socratic philosophy of conceptions is the source from
which these peculiarities are derived, still that philosophy is itself
only the expression of the character of the nation which produced it.
In an earlier work it has been shown [1] that the most distinctive
feature of Greek life lay in confounding the outer and the inner
worlds, in ingenuously assuming that the two originally corresponded,
and are still in perfect harmony with one another. When the whole
mental life of a people bears this impress, it is sure to be reflected
in its philosophy also. Together with the advantages which accrue from
the confusion of the two, philosophy shares also the disadvantages
which unavoidably attend any theory which ignores the real distinction
between them. The mind only gradually and imperfectly becomes aware of
the distinctive peculiarity of mental life, of the notion of
personality, of the fact that moral rights and duties are independent
of external circumstances, of the share of the individual will in
creating ideas. It has also less hesitation in transferring phases of
consciousness directly to things themselves, in regarding the world
from ideal points of view borrowed from the sphere of mind, in
accepting its own notions of things as realities without testing their
actual truth, and even treating them as more real than the reality of
the senses, and in confounding the critical analysis of a notion with
the experimental investigation of a thing. If the philosophy of Greece
in the time of its greatest perfection was not free from these defects;
if, further, these defects were the cause of all the important faults
in the systems of Plato and Aristotle; the creators of these systems
and their immediate successors are not the only ones to blame; but the
whole mental peculiarity of the people is at fault of which within the
province of science these men were the greatest representatives.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account