The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
What therefore the opponents of vaccination demand is, that the
respect thus accorded to the religious conscience be extended
to the scientific conscience--to those who are convinced that
vaccination does not prevent smallpox or is an injurious practice.
Even allowing it to be a harmless ceremony, resistance would be
justifiable. It would be in vain to console a Baptist, forced to
convey his child to the parish font, with the assurance that a
few drops of water could do no harm. It is not in human nature
to submit to the indignity of imposture; and to thousands of
Englishmen vaccination is a cruel and degrading imposture, and
to punish them for their loyalty to what they think right is
every whit as tyrannical as it was for Catholics to persecute
Protestants, and Protestants Catholics, and Catholics and
Protestants Jews. There is no difference in the terms of
intolerance; and there is no difference in the spirit with which
this latter-day tyranny is confronted, and that spirit with which
religious liberty was vindicated and won.
CONDITIONS OF THE CONFLICT.
To some eyes the conflict is not only arduous; it is hopeless;
but we are of a different mind. The conflict may prove even less
arduous than it appears; and for these reasons. The law as it
stands is perfunctorily defended. No politician answers for it
without reluctance. Many allow that a serious mistake was made
when legislation was enacted for medical advantage at medical
dictation. The Gladstone government proposed to abolish repeated
penalties. The central authorities at the Local Government Board
make no secret of the insuperable difficulties which attend the
administration of the law. They advise concession to its resolute
adversaries. They do not reinstate the law where it has broken
down. Legislation thus discredited is sure to collapse under
broader pressure. The medical support is still weaker; and is
chiefly confined to those who represent the trade element of the
profession--men who would defend any abuse however flagrant if
established and lucrative. It is the custom to laud the immortal
Jenner and the salvation he wrought, but these are words of an old
song. Those who have penetrated to the inception of the Jennerian
rite; who know the absolute promise by which it prevailed and its
absolute failure; who have followed its successive transformations
and varieties with their respective injuries and fatalities; who
are aware of the Babel of confusion and contradiction in which
its venal practitioners are involved--these we say recognise how
impossible it is for vaccination to be brought under discussion
and survive. It is this consciousness which accounts for the
reserve of the more prudent order of medical men. They excuse their
acquiescence in the delusion (after the manner of ecclesiastics) by
the exigencies of professional loyalty; and by the supposition that
the harm of the practice is exaggerated, whilst it serves for the
consolation of the vulgar.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account