The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact ChaptersWhite, William
History
The Story of a Great Delusion in a Series of Matter-of-Fact Chapters
White, William
Vaccination
About this time, the Ambassador’s ingenious lady resolved to
submit her only son to it, a very hopeful boy of about six years
of age. She first of all ordered me to find out a fit subject
to take the matter from, and then sent for an old Greek woman
who had practised this way a great many years. After a good deal
of trouble and pains, I found a proper subject, and then the
good woman went to work; but so awkwardly by the shaking of her
hand, and put the child to so much torture with her blunt and
rusty needle, that I pitied his cries, who had ever been of such
spirit and courage that hardly anything of pain could make him
cry before; and, therefore, inoculated the other arm with my own
instrument, and with so little pain to him that he did not in
the least complain of it. The operation took in both arms, and
succeeded perfectly well.... He had about an hundred pox all upon
his body. This operation was performed at Pera in the month of
March, 1717.
That is to say, almost simultaneously with the Ambassador’s arrival
in Turkey.
The embassy returned to England in 1718, after a residence
of little over a year in Constantinople. The dates are worth
observation; for whilst it appears that the doctor and the lady
were in common resolved to recommend the practice of inoculation to
their countrymen, the dates prove with what inexperience and levity
they assumed the grave responsibility. If quackery be assertion
in absence of knowledge or of evidence, then we may accurately
stigmatise Maitland and Montagu a couple of quacks. But so far as
concerns Maitland we may go farther, for he expressly tells us--
I was assured and saw with my eyes that the smallpox is rather
more malignant and epidemic in the Turkish dominions than with
us; insomuch that, as some have affirmed, one-half, or at least
one-third part of the diseased, at certain times, do die of it;
and they that escape are terribly disfigured by it.[15]
Yet this same Maitland, who thus testified of the impotence of
inoculation to mitigate and restrain smallpox in Turkey, came
to England ready to assert its power to mitigate and restrain!
It is difficult to find words of due severity for such impudent
inconsistency. We shall see, however, in the course of this
wonderful story, how every rule of evidence may be defied in the
matter of smallpox, and how it is possible to shut one’s eyes and
prophesy in the name of science, and have noise and hardihood
accepted for veracity.
FOOTNOTES:
[11] _Literary Studies_, Vol. i. p. 248.
[12] Born in Yorkshire, 1713.
[13] _Account of Inoculating for Smallpox._ London, 1722.
[14] _A Short Account of Inoculation._ London, 1723.
[15] _Account of Inoculating for Smallpox_, p. 4.
CHAPTER III.
MAITLAND’S EXPERIMENTS.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account