The Story of Dutch PaintingCaffin, Charles H. (Charles Henry)
History
The Story of Dutch Painting
Caffin, Charles H. (Charles Henry)
Painting, Dutch
position, and the girl stands between them with her hands similarly
raised, only as she holds the necklace she looks up, instead of down to
the table as in the other picture. She wears a canary-colored jacket
edged with ermine, that appears again in Mrs. Collis P. Huntington’s
_Lady with Lute_. In the Berlin picture it sounds a note of liveliness
that is exquisitely sustained in the silvery resonance of the lighted
room; the effect of which is induced by the tones of olive in her skirt
and the table-cloth, by a deep almost colorless blue drapery over the
latter, and a shaft of dull yellow, formed by the velour of the
window-curtain. The ensemble, in fact, is one of piquant decision and
indescribable delicacy, illustrating Vermeer’s faculty of sight
imagination, so that he not only renders what he sees, but actually
creates.
Between Mr. J. Pierpont Morgan’s _Lady Writing_ and _The Lace-Maker_ of
the Louvre there is a remarkable companionship of arrangement and
feeling. In each case the figure is seated, bending over a table; the
jacket is canary-colored, and blue is introduced in the table-cloth of
the former picture and in a cushion in the other, while in both the
sensitive expression of the head and hands is echoed in the delicate
precision of the objects on the table. In both cases the luminosity of
the scene is enhanced by a shadowed mass on the left of the foreground.
Mr. Morgan’s picture in loveliness of color, exquisiteness of handling,
and inexpressibly subtle feeling rivals its sister piece of the Louvre.
It is in this element of feeling alone that these two pictures possibly
excel the _Girl with Water-Jug_ of the Metropolitan Museum. For the
latter’s beauty of color, with its deep bell-like note of blue and the
resonance of blue, more or less faintly hovering over the cap and
kerchief and permeating the atmosphere, is unsurpassable. Perfect also
is the handling of this picture, both as to its suggestion of the
plastic reality of everything represented and its consummate delicacy of
manipulation; while in one particular it surpasses both the others and
is in Vermeer’s finest possible manner. This is the extraordinary
propriety with which each detail of the composition is introduced.
Everything has been selected and placed with the choicest discretion;
nothing is confused or unexplained, everything is a triumph of
incomparable simplicity and exquisite adjustment. Only, I repeat, in
feeling; in the expression of the head, arms, and hands is there lacking
something of the exquisite _finesse_ of the above two pictures and of
certain other examples.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account