The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxisLaidlaw, George Frederick
Science
The Treatment of Hay Fever by rosin-weed, ichthyol and faradic electricity: With a discussion of the old theory of gout and the new theory of anaphylaxis
Laidlaw, George Frederick
Hay fever
Finally, in the great Edinburgh _Encyclopædia Medica_, 1900, Volume 4,
Greville MacDonald, of London, in the article on Hay Fever, seems to
know nothing of the gouty theory and says innocently at the end of the
article, "No special dietary is indicated, seeing that these patients
present no tendency to lithæmia, etc." He makes the extraordinary
suggestion that, in relieving the attack of hay fever, "rather than give
the patient cocaine, it might be wise to allow the opium pipe." In the
early prescriptions for hay fever, opium sprays and nasal douches were
common enough, but this is the only time I ever heard a reputable
physician and a teacher, at that, advising a patient to "hit the pipe."
I think that, from the evidence examined, we may say that British and
American authors know nothing of de Mussy and his theory.
Next, I looked up the gout authorities, Ewart, Ebstein, Garrod,
Falkenstein, Lancereaux, Lecorche, each of whom wrote a bulky treatise
on Gout, but there is never a word on Hay Fever.
=De Mussy in Germany.= For many years, whenever I have wanted to know
anything from the bottom up, historically, linguistically,
philosophically, I have turned to a German book and have always found
what I was looking for, if it is known to man. Where an American or
British author will skim over or touch a subject carelessly, not seeming
to care where the idea comes from or its relation to other ideas in
different times or countries, a German will plow steadily through the
matter from Hammurabi to Wilhelm III and lay bare all the collateral
tributaries and branches, always with an index at the end.
First I tried Heymann's _Handbuch der Laryngologie und Rhinologie_
(Wien, 1900) and found hay fever described in the article on _Die
Nasalen Reflexneurosen_, by Professor Jurasz in Heidelberg; but there
was no mention of gout. By this, I was truly convinced that nothing was
known on the subject. If a Heidelberg Herr Professor does not know it,
it does not exist. And "Professor Jurasz in Heidelberg" had failed me.
However, looking further in Heymann, my faith in German thoroughness and
all-inclusiveness revived. Hay fever appears also in the article on
Acute Rhinitis, by P. H. Gerber, of Königsberg, and here, on page 371,
we find a complete "Literatur" spread out in true Teutonic style from
Bostock to date. However, Gerber does not discuss the matter of gout in
the text, but says merely, "Recently Bishop asserts that the nervous
disturbances of hay fever are due to an excess of uric acid in the
blood."
The gouty theory of hay fever receives scanty recognition from most
German writers. Strümpell does not mention it. In his _Handbuch der
Specielle Pathologie und Therapie_, Berlin and Wien, 1904, Eichorst says
skeptically, page 326, "It has been stated often that gouty families are
especially apt to develop hay fever," and on page 330 "Grote saw hay
fever patients of gouty families cured (?) by a course of waters at
Neuenahr."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account