The third day of the trial, the Chief Justice delivered his written
opinion. “On an application of this kind,” says he, “I certainly
should not require that proof which would be necessary to convict the
person to be committed on a trial in chief; nor should I even require
that which should absolutely convince my own mind of the guilt of the
accused; but I ought to require, and I should require, that probable
cause be shown; and I understand probable cause to be a case made out
by proof furnishing good reason to believe that the crime alleged has
been committed by the person charged with having committed it.” The
Chief Justice then reviews the testimony of General Eaton and General
Wilkinson in the Swartout and Bollman case to show how far these
charges are supported by probable cause, and in conclusion delivers
himself as follows: “I shall not therefore insert in the commitment the
charge of high treason, since it will be entirely in the power of the
Attorney-General to prefer an indictment against the prisoner for high
treason should he be furnished with the necessary testimony.”
Burr was now called upon to give bond, and the amount to be required
of him gave rise to much discussion. The Chief Justice stated, “that
he wished it to be neither too large to amount to oppression, nor
too small to defeat the objects of justice.” It had occurred to
him that the sum of ten thousand dollars would perhaps avoid both
these extremes. Mr. Hay earnestly insisted upon a larger amount, but
the amount was fixed at ten thousand. Burr was then bailed for his
appearance at the next term of the Circuit Court of the United States
to convene at Richmond on the 22d of May next, to answer the charge of
high misdemeanor.
Aaron Burr was now at liberty. President Jefferson was enraged at the
result of the first trial. The feeling between the partisans of the
Administration and the Federalists, to which political party Marshall
belonged, was rampant. The friends of Jefferson charged Marshall
with having permitted his political bias and personal dislike of the
President to warp his judgment in favor of Burr throughout the trial,
and Jefferson in one of his letters to Senator Giles, written a few
days after Burr’s first examination at Richmond, refers to the _tricks_
of the judges in hastening the trial so as to clear Burr. It was
evident that Jefferson was to be the real prosecutor of Burr, and had
made up his mind to convict him at whatever cost.
The 22d of May, 1807, the United States Circuit Court for the Virginia
District convened in the House of Delegates in the City of Richmond,
Virginia, with Chief Justice Marshall and Cyrus Griffin, District
Judge, on the bench.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account