John Randolph, Foreman, Joseph Eggleston, Joseph C. Cabell, Littleton
W. Tazewell, Robert Taylor, James Pleasants, John Brockenbrough,
William Daniel, James M. Garnett, John Mercer, Edward Pegram, Munford
Beverly, John Ambler, Thomas Harrison, Alexander Shephard and James
Barbour.
The Chief Justice promptly delivered an appropriate charge to the
grand jury. He dwelt more particularly upon the definition and nature
of treason, and the testimony requisite to prove it. He said in part:
“To you by the Constitution and laws of our country is confided the
important right of accusing those whose offenses shall have rendered
them subject to punishment under the laws of the United States. It
is on you that the fundamental principles on which the stability of
our political institutions and the safety of individuals most greatly
depend. For to little purpose would laws be formed to protect the
innocent of the body politic from crimes of the worst nature if a
misplaced nonentity should control the execution of them. Juries,
gentlemen, as well as judges, should be superior to every temptation,
which hope, fear or compassion, may suggest; who will allow no
influence to balance their love of justice; who will follow no guide
but the laws of their country.
“In outlining to you, gentlemen of the jury, those offenses which are
cognizable in the court, and which may scarcely be noticed by you,
the first on the calendar, as well as the highest known atrocity,
is treason against the United States. With a jealousy peculiar to
themselves the American people have withdrawn the subject from the
power of their legislature, and have declared in their Constitution
that ‘treason against the United States shall consist only in levying
war against them, or in adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and
comfort.’”
After the grand jury had retired Colonel Burr addressed the court
on the propriety of specially instructing them in regard to the
admissibility of certain evidence, which he stated would be laid before
the grand jury by the attorney for the United States. Mr. Hay opposed
this application. He said he could never agree to it, and he trusted
the court also would never sanction such a suggestion; that Colonel
Burr stood before the court on the same footing as any other citizen,
and he hoped the court would not distinguish between his case and that
of any other. The question was postponed for further discussion. The
court then adjourned to the following morning.
The court met the next day and the grand jury also appeared. It became
apparent that nothing effectual could be done until the arrival of
General Wilkinson, the most important witness for the Government. The
grand jury were therefore adjourned from day to day until he put in his
appearance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account