Once more attention is called to the fact that these discrepancies
negative completely the idea that the Gospel writers were conspirators,
bent upon the common purpose of deceiving mankind by publishing a false
history to the world. Nothing could be more absurd than to suppose that
men conspiring to perpetrate a fraud, would neglect a fundamental
principle underlying all successful conspiracy; that is, the creation
and maintenance of a due and reasonable consistency between the words
and deeds of the conspirators in formulating plans for carrying out the
common purpose. Then, if there was no previous concert, the fact that
four men, writing at different times and places, concurred in framing
substantially the same history, is one of the strongest proofs of the
credibility of the writers and the truthfulness of their narratives. And
on this point the testimony of a very great writer may be quoted: that
"in a number of concurrent testimonies, where there has been no previous
concert, there is a probability distinct from that which may be termed
the sum of the probabilities resulting from the testimonies of the
witnesses; a probability which would remain, even though the witnesses
were of such a character as to merit no faith at all. This probability
arises from the concurrence itself. That such a concurrence should
spring from chance is as one to infinite; that is, in other words,
morally impossible. If, therefore, concert be excluded, there remains no
cause but the reality of the fact."[25]
Apply the theory of probability, arising from concurrent testimonies,
where there has been no previous concert, to the case of the
Evangelists, and we are at once convinced that they were truthful and
that their histories are true.
(4) Let us now consider the _conformity of the testimony of the
Evangelists with human experience_. This is the fourth legal test of the
credibility of witnesses prescribed by Starkie.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account