use it as a means of invading England—the thought of which, in 1914,
caused one prominent English anti-tunneler, Admiral Sir Algernon de
Horsey, publicly to characterize as "unworthy of consideration" the
dissenting views of pro-tunnelers, whom he contemptuously referred
to as "those poor creatures who have no stomach for an hour's sea
passage, and who think retention of their dinners more important than
the safety of their country." Over the years, anti-tunnel forces have
used as ammunition an extraordinary variety of further arguments, which
have ranged from objections about probable customs difficulties at the
English and French ends of the tunnel to suspicions that a Channel
tunnel would make it easier for international Socialists to commingle
and conspire.
Behind all these given reasons, no matter how elaborate or how special
they might be, there has always lurked something else, a consideration
more subtle, more elusive, more profound, and less answer able than
any specific objections to the construction of a Channel tunnel—the
consideration of England's traditional insular position, the feeling
that somehow, if England were to be connected by a tunnel with the
Continent, the peculiar meaning, to an Englishman, of being English
would never be quite the same again. It is this feeling, no doubt, that
in 1882 motivated an article on the tunnel, in so sober a publication
as _The Solicitors' Journal_, to express about it an uneasiness
bordering on alarm, on the ground that, if successful, the construction
of a tunnel would "effect a change in the natural geographical
condition of things." And it is no doubt something of the same feeling
that prompted Lord Randolph Churchill, during a speech attacking a bill
for a Channel tunnel before the House of Commons in 1889—the bill
was defeated, of course—to observe skillfully that "the reputation
of England has hitherto depended upon her being, as it were, _virgo
intacta_."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account