The Yale Literary Magazine (Vol. LXXXIX, No. 1, 1923)Various
General
The Yale Literary Magazine (Vol. LXXXIX, No. 1, 1923)
Various
College students' writings, American -- Connecticut -- New Haven -- Periodicals; Yale University -- Periodicals
The recognized place for specialization is the graduate school. The
graduate student works presumably in a special atmosphere created by
the common labors of a common group for a common end; the end being
a particular degree desired because it has come to signify that the
bearer of such a symbol has mastered the details of a recognized
branch of learning. A graduate school is the most suitable medium
for accomplishing the task in hand. It is the only reason we have
post-graduate schools at all.
The existing situation in the college is exactly the reverse. Those who
are working for the B.A. degree and nothing else are carrying on side
by side with what are in reality pre-medical students and first-year
lawyers. Out of this have sprung two separate points of view on the
same campus. On the one hand there is a group which pursues its studies
with the realization that upon the complete mastery of every detail
depends in a large measure the success or failure of its life-work. On
the other, there remain those who are still searching in their work
for that particular field which to them will seem to be the one to
which they wish to devote their future time and energy. The result is a
repetition of the old story of the house divided against itself. It is
just this condition, we believe, that has led to such restless, groping
questionings as, “What is Yale for?” The definition of a university as
being one body of which there are many members admirably illustrates
the point. For the college to-day is in the anomalous position of
attempting to perform the duties of two members where it formerly
functioned as one. Such a state of affairs is not conducive to the
health of any organization whatever.
The solution in the minds of many seems to lie in the abolishment
of the old college course, following the law of the survival of the
fittest. This issue of our present afflictions we believe would be a
regretable blunder. There should always be a place for the study of the
so-called liberal arts; for the contemplation of “all the best that has
been thought and said and done in the world”. Without such a background
many a man cannot do his best work. What place is better fitted to
continue this undertaking than Yale, established in this spirit, as
attested by the words of the founder, “I give these books for the
founding of a college”? Professor Mather in a recent address summed up
the ideal of the college in these glowing terms:
“The college does its work alongside a dozen other equally worthy
educational institutions, mostly vocational. It does not compete with
them; it directly supplements them and incidentally aids them. It has
its own aims, which are not immediately practical, vocational, or
material.
“I should like to see inscribed over our college portals the following
inscription:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account