Thrasymachus : $b or, The future of moralsJoad, C. E. M. (Cyril Edwin Mitchinson)
Philosophy
Thrasymachus : $b or, The future of morals
Joad, C. E. M. (Cyril Edwin Mitchinson)
Ethics
Conformity rather than intelligence is more particularly required of
those who seek to instruct the young. A man’s ability to demonstrate
the differential calculus or impart the facts of history would not, it
is true, appear to be lessened by his having passed through the divorce
court. Yet there is no doubt that such an event will cast a blight upon
his career as a teacher. People are too satisfied with their own ways
of thought and habits of conduct to wish for their children anything
better than that they should think and act as they do themselves. What
is demanded of the teacher, therefore, is that he should transmit to
the children the same beliefs as those which are held by their parents.
He must hold up to their admiration those things which their parents
consider to be admirable, such as God, vaccination, monogamy, the
Treaty of Versailles and the capitalist system, and speak with scorn
and contempt of Bolshevism, atheism, Germany, free love and agitators,
whom parents consider to be evil. When the teacher does this he is what
is called a safe man. He inspires confidence and obtains preferment.
Provided, in short, that he guarantees not to teach anything new, his
capacity to teach anything at all is not seriously questioned. And,
since the best minds of every generation, being in advance of their
time, would prefer not to teach at all rather than to perpetuate the
dogmas in which they have ceased to believe, the successful teacher is
not always remarkable for intelligence.
In any event, whether intelligent or not, he must conform, and will
have to do so increasingly. The herd morality which drove a statesman
of the calibre of Dilke out of public life because it disapproved
of his private life, is, after a temporary relapse, increasing in
strength, and in the immediate future nobody who does not profess the
morality to which the middle classes adhere will stand any chance of
public office. If a man’s actions belie his professions he must be
careful to conceal them.
One of the results of this development will be an increase in
hypocrisy. To-day the agnostic don at Oxford worships regularly in
the College Chapel, and men will be driven increasingly to give
lip-service to ideals and shibboleths which in their hearts they
despise. In general, the gulf which separates public profession and
private practice, a gulf which has made England a byword for hypocrisy,
will grow wider. Driven to profess the beliefs of shopkeepers, men will
rely increasingly upon their private judgment as a sanction for their
conduct. Hence the attempt to impose a uniform standard based upon an
obsolete morality upon our public men may lead to a revival of that
unfashionable organ the private conscience, and those from whom an
unwilling conformity is exacted in public, will insist that they and
they alone are the judges of what is right and wrong in private.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account