Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
History
Towards an enduring peace : $b A symposium of peace proposals and programs 1914-1916
Peace; World War, 1914-1918 -- Peace
Most people who have been thinking seriously about the maintenance of
peace are tending to the opinion that a sanction of some kind is needed
to enforce the observance of treaties and of agreements for arbitration.
Among the measures proposed has been that of an international police
force, under the control of a central council which could use it to
preserve order throughout the world. At present such a plan seems
visionary. The force would have to be at least large enough to cope with
the army that any single nation could put into the field—under existing
conditions let us say five millions of men fully equipped and supplied
with artillery and ammunition for a campaign of several months. These
troops need not be under arms, or quartered near The Hague, but they
must be thoroughly trained and ready to be called out at short notice.
Practically that would entail yearly votes of the legislative bodies of
each of the nations supplying a quota; and if any of them failed to make
the necessary appropriation there would be great difficulty in preventing
others from following its example. The whole organization would,
therefore, be in constant danger of going to pieces.
[Sidenote: The U. S. and the international police.]
But quite apart from the practical difficulties in the permanent
execution of such a plan, let us see how it would affect the United
States. The amount of the contingents of the various countries would
be apportioned with some regard to population, wealth, and economic
resources; and if the total were five million men, our quota on a
moderate estimate might be five hundred thousand men. Is it conceivable
that the United States would agree to keep anything like that number
drilled, equipped, and ready to take the field on the order of an
international council composed mainly of foreign nations? Of course it
will be answered that these figures are exaggerated, because any such
plan will be accompanied by a reduction in armaments. But that is an
easier thing to talk about than to effect, and especially to maintain.
One must not forget that the existing system of universal compulsory
military service on the continent of Europe arose from Napoleon’s attempt
to limit the size of the Prussian army. He would be a bold or sanguine
man who should assert that any treaty to limit armaments could not in
like manner be evaded; and however much they were limited, the quantity
of troops to be held at the disposal of a foreign council would of
necessity be large, while no nation would be willing to pledge for the
purpose the whole of its military force. Such a plan may be practicable
in some remote future when the whole world is a vast federation under
a central government, but that would seem to be a matter for coming
generations, not for the men of our day.
Moreover, the nations whose troops were engaged in fighting any country
would inevitably find themselves at war with that country.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account