Two methods of estimating the cost of tunnel work are employed. The
first is to calculate the probable expense of the various items of work,
based upon the available data, per unit of length, and then add to this
a margin of at least 10% to allow for contingencies; the second is to
apply to the new work the unit cost of some previous tunnel built under
substantially the same conditions. In the first method it is usual to
consider the strutting and hauling as constituting a part of the work
of excavation. To estimate the cost of excavation involves the
consideration of three general items, viz., the excavation proper, the
strutting of the walls of the excavation, and the hauling of the
excavated materials and the materials of construction.
The cost of excavating the preliminary headings or drifts is greater per
unit of material removed than that of excavating the enlargement of the
section. The cost of bottom drifts is also always greater than that of
top headings, the material penetrated remaining the same. Mr. Rziha
gives the comparative unit costs of excavating drifts, headings, and
enlargement of the profile as follows:--
Bottom drifts $9.20 per cu. yd.
Top headings 4.80 „ „ „
Enlargement of profile 2.84 „ „ „
The cost of hauling increases with the length of the tunnel. This fact
and amount of this increase are indicated by the following actual prices
for the Arlberg tunnel:--
Top heading $6.76 per cu. yd., increasing 37 cts. per mile
Bottom drift 7.40 „ „ „ „ 26 „ „ „
Enlargement of profile 2.70 „ „ „ „ 10 „ „ „
In all the prices given above, the cost of strutting and hauling is
included in the cost of excavation.
The cost of excavation is not always the same for the same character of
materials in different tunnels. The following figures show the prices
paid for the excavation of calcareous rock in four different German
tunnels:--
Berliner Nordhausen Wetzler R.R. $1.24 per cu. yd.
Ofen 1.30 „ „ „
Stafflach 2.76 „ „ „
Gries 1.92 „ „ „
The method of tunneling has little influence upon the cost of the work,
as shown by the following figures from tunnels excavated through
calcareous rock by different methods:--
Ofen tunnel Austrian method $93.19 per lin. ft.
Dorremberg tunnel Belgian method 86.08 „ „ „
Stafflach tunnel English method 91.69 „ „ „
The Martha and Merten tunnels, excavated through soft ground by the
Austrian and German methods respectively, cost $87.95 and $87.55 per
lin. ft. respectively. In the excavation of the various sections of the
tunnel for the new Croton Aqueduct in America, the following prices were
paid:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account