Church and college -- Ireland; Education, Higher -- Ireland; Universities and colleges -- Ireland
Trinity College, however, although considered dangerous, has never been
placed by the Roman Catholic Clergy in the same category as the Queen's
Colleges, which are essentially secularized institutions, without a
recognized religion, and "godless:" as such they are absolutely condemned
by the Hierarchy, and faithful Catholics are prohibited from entering their
walls.
The practical effect of secularizing Trinity College, if the experiment
were successful, would be to convert it into a fourth Queen's College, and
it would thus become one of a class of Educational Institutions which the
Church of Rome has always, and consistently, forbidden her children to
enter. It is hard to see how such a plan as this can be rationally
advocated, on the ground that it would satisfy the just demands of the
Catholics of Ireland.
So far, therefore, as Irish Roman Catholics are concerned, the
secularization of Trinity College would be to them a loss, and not a gain;
for it would transfer education in this College from the list of dangerous
to that of prohibited enjoyments.
I need scarcely add how mean and vindictive would be the spirit that would
secularize Trinity College, in order to injure the Irish Protestants,
without any corresponding benefit to the Irish Catholics.
I believe, therefore, that it would be impolitic for the English Parliament
to secularize Trinity College, for the following reasons:--
1. It would irritate the Irish Protestants to deprive them of a College
founded on the principles of their Church, which has done its duty,
and has possessed their confidence for three centuries.
2. It would not satisfy the just demand of the Irish Catholics for
University Education, merely to admit them to the Fellowships and
Scholarships of a secularized College, the principle of which they
must feel bound to condemn.
II. NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF IRELAND.
The second plan that has been suggested for solving the University question
in Ireland, in one form or other, amounts to a proposal to throw open the
University of Dublin, or the Queen's University in Ireland, or both, so as
to embrace in one University a number of Colleges, each retaining its own
system of religious training and discipline, and its own endowments, and
sending up its Students to pass the Examinations of the Central University,
whose functions would be reduced to those of an Examining Board.
I readily admit that this proposal is free from one of the objections I
have urged against the proposal to solve the University problem by
secularizing Trinity College, and that it leaves both Protestants and
Catholics free to train their sons in the religious faith and traditions of
their forefathers.
This advantage, although great, would, however, in my opinion, be purchased
at the cost of degrading for ever the standard of University Education in
Ireland.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account