American essays -- 20th century; State, The; World War, 1914-1918
in massed defense or massed attack. Having no such images, he has no
feeling of patriotism. He still feels himself inextricably a part of
this blundering, wistful, crass civilization we call America. All he
asks is not to be identified with it for warlike ends. He does not feel
pro-German. He tells me there is not a drop of any but British blood in
his veins. He does not love the Kaiser. He is quite willing to believe
that it is the German government and not the German people whom he is
asked to fight, although it may be the latter whom he is obliged to
kill. But he cannot forget that it is the American government rather
than the American people who got up the animus to fight the German
government. He does not forget that the American government, having
through tragic failure slipped into the war-technique, is now trying
to manipulate him into that war-technique. And my friend’s idea of
_patria_ does not include the duty of warlike animus, even when the
government decides such animus is necessary to carry out its theories
of democracy and the future organization of the world. There are ways
in which my friend would probably be willing to die for his country.
If his death now meant the restoration of those ravaged lands and the
bringing back of the dead, that would be a cause to die for. But he
knows that the dead cannot be brought back or the brotherly currents
restored. The work of madness will not be undone. Only a desperate war
will be prolonged. Everything seems to him so mad that there is nothing
left worth dying for. _Pro patria mori_, to my friend, means something
different from lying gaunt as a conscript on a foreign battlefield,
fallen in the last desperate fling of an interminable world-war.
Does this mean that if he is drafted he will refuse to serve? I do
not know. It will not be any plea of “conscientious objection” that
keeps him back. That phrase to him has already an archaic flavor
which implies a ruling norm, a stiff familiar whom he must obey in
the matter. It implies that one would be delighted to work up one’s
blood-lust for the business, except that this unaccountable conscience,
like a godly grandmother, absolutely forbids. In the case of my friend,
it will not be any objective “conscience.” It will be something that
is woven into his whole modern philosophic feel for life. This is what
paralyzes him against taking one step toward the war-machine. If he
were merely afraid of death, he would seek some alternative service.
But he does not. He remains passive and apathetic, waiting for the
knife to fall. There is a growing cynicism in him about the brisk and
inept bustle of war-organization. His attitude suggests that if he is
worked into war-service, he will have to be coerced every step of the
way.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account