West Port Murders: Or an Authentic Account of the Atrocious Murders Committed by Burke and His Associates; Containing a Full Account of All the Extraordinary Circumstances Connected With Them. Also, a Report of the Trial of Burke and M'Dougal. With a Description of the Execution of Burke, His Confessions, and Memoirs of His Accomplices, Including the Proceedings Against Hare, &c.Anonymous
History
West Port Murders: Or an Authentic Account of the Atrocious Murders Committed by Burke and His Associates; Containing a Full Account of All the Extraordinary Circumstances Connected With Them. Also, a Report of the Trial of Burke and M'Dougal. With a Description of the Execution of Burke, His Confessions, and Memoirs of His Accomplices, Including the Proceedings Against Hare, &c.
charged in the indictment; but these were clearly _partes ejusdem
negotii_; they were committed in immediate sequence and in furtherance
of the same “foul and atrocious design.” It was quite plain, therefore,
that the cases quoted did not apply; that they had no bearing whatever
on the present case, where three different and unconnected murders
were charged against the same individual, and where another party was
mixed up with him in one of the alleged crimes. Were they not entitled,
then, to ask their Lordships, in the exercise of a sound discretion,
(which it was not denied the Court possessed) “to divide and parcel
out” the charges in this indictment, and to find it incompetent to
go to trial upon it as it presently stood? The Learned Counsel then
adverted to the state of the law of England on this subject, commenting
on the passage quoted by Mr. Robertson from the work of Chitty, and
concluded by observing that this was in all respects a most serious
case, and deserved the utmost attention of the Court. No instance of
three murders charged in one indictment had happened in his time; many
instances had indeed occurred in former times; yet it had never been
the practice to try the charges _in cumulo_. But the more anomalous
and unprecedented the case, the more necessary was it to the ends of
justice, and the more important to the law, that it should be proceeded
in with the utmost caution.
Their Lordships then delivered their opinions on the objection which
had been raised and so ably argued by the prisoner’s Counsel.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account