What Prohibition Has Done to AmericaFranklin, Fabian
History
What Prohibition Has Done to America
Franklin, Fabian
Prohibition -- United States; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
And so it is with the basic principles of legislation. To forbid the
use of narcotic drugs is a restraint of liberty of the same _kind_ as
to forbid the use of alcoholic liquors; but in _degree_ the two are
wide as the poles asunder. The use of narcotic drugs (except as
medicine) is so unmitigatedly harmful that there is perhaps hardly a
human being who contends that it is otherwise. People _crave_ it, but
they are ashamed of the craving. It plays no part in any acknowledged
form of human intercourse; it is connected with no joys or benefits
that normal human beings openly prize. A thing which is so wholly evil,
and which, moreover, so swiftly and insidiously renders powerless the
will of those who--perhaps by some accident--once begin to indulge in
it, stands outside the category alike of the ordinary objects of human
desire and the ordinary causes of human degradation. To make an
exception to the principle of liberty in such a case is to do just what
common sense dictates in scores of instances where the strict
application of a general principle to extreme cases would involve an
intolerable sacrifice of good in order to remove a mere superficial
appearance of wrong. To make the prohibition of narcotic drugs an
adequate reason for not objecting to the prohibition of alcoholic
drinks would be like calling upon physicians to throw into the scrap
heap their principle of the absolute sanctity of human life because
they do not apply that principle with literal rigor in cases where to
do so would be an act of inhuman and unmitigated cruelty.
CHAPTER X
PROHIBITION AND SOCIALISM
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account