Historians -- United States -- Biography; Prescott, William Hickling, 1796-1859
manner becomes like Mr. Prescott's _notes_; levity is mistaken for
ease, an un-'pertinent' familiarity for intimacy, second-rate
low-toned 'jocularities' (which make no one laugh but the retailer)
for the light, hair-trigger repartee, the brilliancy of high-bred
pleasantry. Mr. Prescott emulates Dr. Channing in his text, Dr.
Dunham and Mr. Joseph Miller in his notes. Judging from the facetiæ
which, by his commending them as 'good,' have furnished a gauge to
measure his capacity for relishing humour, we are convinced that
his non-perception of wit is so genuine as to be organic. It is
perfectly allowable to rise occasionally from the ludicrous into
the serious, but to descend from history to the bathos of
balderdash is too bad--_risu inepto nihil ineptius_."
This passage, which is an amusing example of an overflow of High Tory
bile, does not by any means fairly represent the general tone of Ford's
review. Prescott had here and there indulged himself in some of the
commonplaces of republicanism such as were usual in American writings of
that time; and these harmlessly trite political pedantries had rasped
the nerves of his British reviewer. To speak of "the empty decorations,
the stars and garters of an order of nobility," to mention "royal
perfidy," "royal dissimulation," "royal recompense of ingratitude," and
generally to intimate that "the people" were superior to royalty and
nobility, roused a spirit of antagonism in the mind of Mr. Ford. Several
of Prescott's semi-facetious notes dealt with rank and aristocracy in
something of the same hold-cheap tone, so that Ford was irritated into a
very personal retort. He wrote:--
"These pleasantries come with a bad grace from the son, as we learn
from a full-length dedication, of 'the _Honourable_ William
Prescott, _LL.D._' We really are ignorant of the exact value of
this titular potpourri in a _soi-disant_ land of equality, of these
noble and academic plumes, borrowed from the wing of a professedly
despised monarchy."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account