Wit and its relation to the unconsciousFreud, Sigmund
Science
Wit and its relation to the unconscious
Freud, Sigmund
Subconsciousness; Wit and humor -- Psychological aspects
This variety causes confusion. It might vex us because we have devoted
so much time to the consideration of the technical means of wit, and the
stress laid on the forms might possibly arouse our suspicions that we
are overvaluing their importance so far as the knowledge of the nature
of wit is concerned. But this conjecture is met by the one irrefutable
fact: namely, that each time the wit disappears as soon as we remove the
effect that was brought to expression by these techniques. We are thus
directed to search for the unity in this variety. It must be possible to
bring all these techniques under one head. As we have remarked before,
it is not difficult to unite the second and third groups, for the double
meaning, the play on words, is nothing but the ideal case of utilizing
the same material. The latter is here apparently the more comprehensive
conception. The examples of dividing, changing the order of the same
material, manifold application with slight modifications (c, d, e)—all
these could, without difficulty, be subordinated under the conception of
double meaning. But what community exists between the technique of the
first group—condensation with substitutive formation—and the two other
groups—manifold application of the same material?
_The Tendency to Economy_
It seems to me that this agreement is very simple and clear. The
application of the same material is only a special case of condensation
and the play on words is nothing but a condensation without substitutive
formation. Condensation thus remains as the chief category. A
compressing or—to be more exact—an economic tendency controls all these
techniques. As Prince Hamlet says: “Thrift, Horatio, thrift.” It seems
to be all a matter of economy.
Let us examine this economy in individual cases. “_C’est le premier vol
de l’aigle._” That is, the first flight of the eagle. Certainly, but it
is a depredatious flight. Luckily for the gist of this joke “vol”
signifies flight as well as depredation. Has nothing been condensed and
economized by this? Certainly, the entire second thought, and it was
dropped without any substitution. The double sense of the word “vol”
makes such substitution superfluous, or what is just as correct: The
word “vol” contains the substitution for the repressed thought without
the necessity of supplementing or varying the first sentence. Therein
consists the benefit of the double meaning.
Another example: _Gold mine_,—_gold spoon_, the enormous economy of
expression the single word “gold” produces. It really tells the history
of two generations in the life of some American families. The father
made his fortune through hard toiling in the gold fields during the
early pioneer days. The son was born with a golden spoon in his mouth;
having been brought up as the son of a wealthy man, he becomes a chronic
alcoholic and has to take the gold cure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account