Socialists like to talk about abolishing class distinction. They know
that this is one of the most attractive proposals that they can dangle
before the envious and the ignorant. Yet what have we here but the
establishment of two distinct classes--the directing or “bossing”
class, and the obeying or working class? That Socialism would institute
changes, there can be no doubt, but it would be a change in bosses,
not a change in methods. As Professor Flint has said (“Socialism,” p.
373), “it would place the masses of mankind completely at the mercy of
a comparatively small and highly centralized body of organizers and
administrators entrusted with such power as no human hand can safely
and righteously wield.”
Hobhouse in “Democracy and Reaction” (p. 228), clearly defines what
this must mean:
“As the ‘expert’ comes to the front and ‘efficiency’ becomes the
watchword of administration, all that was human in Socialism vanishes
out of it. Its tenderness for the losers in the race, its protests
against class tyranny, its revolt against commercial materialism,”
all the sources of the Socialist doctrines are gone like a dream,
and “instead we have the conception of society as a perfect piece of
machinery pulled by wires radiating from a single centre, and all men
and women are either ‘experts’ or puppets.”
It is thus that humanity, liberty and justice must vanish under
Socialism, for the ultimate result, said Mr. Spencer (“A Plea for
Liberty,” p. 26), “must be a society like that of ancient Peru ... in
which the mass of the people, elaborately regimented in groups of 10,
50, 100, 500 and 1,000, ruled by officers of corresponding grades and
tied to their districts, were superintended in their private lives as
well as in their industries, and toiled hopelessly for the government
organization.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account