Thus it is evident that the doctrine of the Earth’s rotundity cannot
be mixed up with the practical operations of civil engineers and
surveyors, and to prevent the waste of time and the destruction of
property which necessarily followed the doings of some who were
determined to involve the convexity of the Earth’s surface in their
calculations, the very Government of the country has been obliged to
interfere! Every survey of this and other countries, whether ordnance
or otherwise, is now carried out in connection with a horizontal datum,
and therefore, as no other method proves satisfactory, it is virtually
an admission by all the most practical scientific men of the day that
the Earth _cannot be other than a plane_!
An argument for the Earth’s convexity is thought by many to be found
in the following facts:--“Fluid or semi-fluid substances in a state
of motion invariably assume the globular form, as rain, hail, dew,
mercury, and melted lead, which, poured from a great height becomes
divided into spherical masses, as in the manufacture of small shot,
&c.” “There is abundant evidence from geology that the Earth has been
a fluid or semi-fluid mass, and it could not, therefore, continue in
a state of motion through space without becoming spherical.” Without
denying that the Earth has been, at some former period, in a pulpy or
semi-fluid state, it is requisite to prove beyond all doubt that it
has a motion upon axes and through space, or the conclusion that it
is therefore spherical is premature and illogical. It will be shown
in a subsequent part of this work, that such axial and orbital motion
does not exist, and therefore any argument founded upon and including
it as a fact is necessarily fallacious. In addition to this, it may
be remarked that the tendency in falling fluids to become globular is
owing to what has been called “attraction of cohesion” (not “attraction
of gravitation”), which is very limited in its operation. It is
confined to small quantities of matter. If, in the manufacture of
small shot, the melted metal is allowed to fall in masses of several
ounces or pounds, instead of being divided into particles weighing
only a few grains, it will never take a spherical form, and shot of
an inch in diameter could not be made by this process. Bullets of
even half-an-inch diameter can only be made by casting the metal into
spherical moulds. In tropical countries, the rain instead of falling in
drops or small globules, often comes down in large irregular masses,
which have no approximation whatever to sphericity. So that it is
manifestly unjust to affirm of large masses of matter like the Earth
that which only belongs to minute portions or a few grains in weight.
The whole matter taken together entirely fails as an argument for the
Earth’s rotundity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account