Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
For many centuries in Ionia and Athens there was an almost open state of
sex-war. At Miletus a woman never sat at table with her husband, for he
was the enemy with whom bread must not be broken; at Athens, while all
the men went free, women were kept as slaves, and a stranger in the harem
might be killed at sight. The sexes were sharply separated: men and women
had but few opportunities for mutual esteem and affection, and domestic
life—the life of the home, the wife and the children—was poisoned at its
source.
The causes and results of this war, far worse than any faction or civil
strife, are lamentable enough: its manifestations in ancient literature
are perhaps even more important, for it is hard to say how far current
opinions of feminine disabilities are not unconsciously due to the
long line of writers, Greek and Latin, from Simonides of Amorgos, in
the seventh century before Christ, to Juvenal in the second century of
our era, who used all their powers of rhetoric and literary skill to
disparage and depreciate womankind. In the whole deplorable business men
were in the wrong, and they therefore took the aggressive. They applied
to women the comforting doctrine of Aristotle, that some people were
slaves because they were made by nature to be slaves: women were men’s
moral inferiors, and therefore it was men’s duty to keep them down.
At Sparta certainly, and perhaps in North Greece, women occupied a very
different place. Spartan women were regarded as free human beings, and
the relations between the sexes were inestimably better than at Athens.
But Sparta, Thessaly, Macedonia, have no direct representation in Greek
literature; we get their point of view only in the writings of some
Athenians, such as Plato and Xenophon, who rebelled against the current
institutions of their state, and in the Alexandrian poets, Apollonius
and Theocritus, who, even in the midst of the luxurious city, kept some
of the freshness of their native hills. Most of the great writers came
from Ionia or from Athens: the Ionians are nearly all misogynists,
and have succeeded in colouring many parts of the Homeric poems with
their perverse immorality: the typical Athenian, and those foreigners
who found their ideal in Athens—Herodotus, Sophocles, Thucydides, the
Orators—usually treat women as a negligible quantity.
Æschylus was an original thinker, and in this, as in many ways, took a
different view from most of his countrymen. But it is not until we come
to Euripides that we get the woman’s side of the case definitely stated.
Euripides ventured to doubt man’s infallibility: he put the doctrine of
the nobility of man, as he put the other doctrines of the nobility of
race and the nobility of war, to the touchstone of a really critical
intelligence, and he came to a conclusion very different from that which
is expressed by the great majority of his predecessors.