Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle — Aristotle — John Shaqi
Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
It must be remembered that the Homeric poems were not written to suit the
taste of the old Mediterranean people, who, if we may trust the evidence
of archæology and certain signs in their language, had but a low code of
sexual morality, and were inclined to regard women as mere instruments of
pleasure. The Epic, in its original shape, was composed for the Achæan
chiefs who came down into Greece from Central Europe, and in sexual
matters were rather of the Scandinavian type. But the Achæans were
only a small ruling class, and were soon assimilated by the conquered
peoples, whose language they adopted. A second tide of invasion by the
northern tribes called Dorian led to somewhat more permanent results,
but the original Mediterranean race was always far superior in numbers,
and unless inter-marriage was prohibited by law it was only a matter
of time for the primary racial type to reappear. Hence the interest of
Greek history, which is one long process of inter-blending and change:
the renascence of the conquered and the gradual disappearance of the
conquerors. Hence also the difference of view in all feminist matters
between Homer and much of the later Greek literature.
The Odyssey especially, which, though perhaps later in composition
than the original Iliad, has been less worked over and received fewer
additions, is based on an entirely different idea of woman’s position
from that which was held after the seventh century B.C. Samuel Butler’s
theory that the Odyssey was composed by a woman, perhaps Nausicaa
herself, is hardly capable of exact proof, but at any rate women in the
Odyssey are never degraded as they are in many of the later passages of
the Iliad, and the one lewd passage, the first lay of Demodocus (in Book
8), ‘the loves of Ares and Aphrodite,’ is a plain interpolation, and a
clumsy one at that. Women indeed pull the strings in the Odyssey: the
goddess Athena, the nymphs, Calypso and Circe, and the mortals, Penelope
and Nausicaa, are the principal actors in the drama. With both these
latter there are traces of the old German custom of Mutterrecht: the
kingship of the tribe seems to go on the woman’s side. The claimants
to Odysseus’ chieftainship seek it through his wife; Nausicaa is the
only daughter, and her marriage is of importance to all the tribe. So
Calypso and Circe are represented as island-queens, living in independent
sovereignty, and normally unconcerned with male companionship. Odysseus
is to both very much in the position of a prince consort, and, being an
active man, suffers severely from lack of occupation and lack of power.
Athena is the guiding spirit of the whole action, and takes a motherly
interest in the hero, but otherwise she is pure intelligence superior to
man and quite free from any desire for man’s society.