Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle — Aristotle — John Shaqi
Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
There remain the _Electra_ and the _Antigone_, and the first of these
is a signal example of the importance for a dramatist of choice of
subject. Æschylus and Euripides have both left us plays dealing with
the same story, and a comparison with the three tragedies will reveal
the essential differences between the three poets. A dramatist must
share—imaginatively at least—in his characters’ thoughts; and women
like Clytemnestra and Electra were so beyond the range of Sophocles’
experience and sympathy that he is quite unable to make them live. Like
everything that Sophocles wrote, the _Electra_ is full of literary
accomplishment. The epic method, for example, is most ingeniously adapted
to the theatre, and a vivid narrative of the chariot race in which
Orestes is supposed to meet his death forms the centre of the play, but
there is no real grip on the dramatic situation: it is literature, not
life.
In the _Antigone_, on the other hand, the poet is dealing with a subject
thoroughly congenial to his temperament, the conflict between law and the
individual, and one independent of sex, and the play is a magnificent
example of his art.
Here certainly the central figure is a woman, or, at least, a girl; but
the interest does not depend upon her sex, for little dramatic use is
made of the Hæmon episode. It is not her sex but her social position that
affects the problem of the play, a problem vital enough in itself without
any sex interest—‘How far is an individual justified in setting his or
her conscience against the law of the State?’
Antigone is a girl orphan, born out of legal wedlock, a slave without a
master; and it is a crowning stroke of irony to pit her lonely figure
against the majesty of man-made law. To modern readers she seems
intensely pathetic, and an Athenian audience would, doubtless, have
sympathised with her as a rebel, if not as a woman. There is no word
in Greek for ‘to command,’ and their only word for ‘to obey’ means
literally ‘to allow oneself to be persuaded,’ so that the conscientious
objector was not uncommon. But Sophocles had been a general, and knew by
experience the way of Athenian soldiers, and it is not certain that he
appreciates his heroine’s wilfulness in quite so favourable a light; for,
as we see in his other plays, he was essentially on the side of law. He
was rather an observer, with a wonderful command of language, than an
original thinker or critic of the established order; and it is a curious
turn of fortune for a poet, who had by no means a close or a sympathetic
knowledge of woman’s character, that the _Antigone_, the only play where
a woman takes a vital part, should be by far the greatest of his works.