Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle — Aristotle — John Shaqi
Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
Helen, to the later Greeks the type of the wanton, appears in the Odyssey
as the faithful wife, respected and self-respecting, of King Menelaus.
She lives in his palace, busy with domestic duties, and when she thinks
of the past it is to rejoice over her return home and escape from Troy,
‘where,’ she says, ‘I used to mourn over the cruel fate which Aphrodite
sent upon me, when she led me from my beloved country, leaving behind
me my daughter, my home, and my husband dear, who lacked nothing of
perfection in mind or in body.’ It is a very different picture from
that of Paris’ mistress, as we have her in later stories, flying with a
foreign youth from her lawful lord, and betraying her too fond master.
So Clytemnestra—after the lyric poets of the seventh and sixth centuries
had worked up her story—is that most dreadful figure to King Man, the
regicide, the woman who dares, by craft and guile, to kill the man set
over her as ruler. In all the later stories it is Clytemnestra who
arranges the details of Agamemnon’s death—the bath, the enveloping
robe, and the axe; it is she who deals the fatal blow, while her lover,
Ægisthus, is a cowardly nonentity, entirely under the dominion of the
woman.
But in the Odyssey the story is very different. It is told twice—by
Agamemnon to Odysseus in Hades, and by Nestor to Telemachus at Pylos, and
this last version is significant enough to be given word for word:
We Greeks (says Nestor) were lingering over there at Troy, and
many a task did we fulfil. But he—Ægisthus—at his ease in the
quiet valleys of Argos, where the horses feed, tried to beguile
the wife of Agamemnon with soft words. At first, of course,
fair Clytemnestra refused to do the shameful thing, for she
was a woman of honest heart. Moreover, there was with her a
minstrel, whom Agamemnon, when he went to Troy, had bidden to
protect his wife. But soon the fate of heaven encompassed the
minstrel, and brought him to his death, for Ægisthus took him
to a desert island and left him there, a prey for the birds to
tear asunder. As for the queen—he willing and she willing—he
led her to his house. And many a sacrifice did he offer to the
gods when he had done that great deed, which never in his heart
had he expected to accomplish.
Such is the passage, and the last two sentences are a literal translation
of the lines which appear thus in Pope’s version:
Then virtue was no more: her guard away,
She fell, to lust a voluntary prey.
Even to the temple stalked the adulterous spouse
With impious thanks and mockery of vows.
For these are the dangers of poetical translation.
But more important than any single character or episode is the general
impression given by the whole poem, and it may fairly be said that the
entire framework of the Odyssey presupposes a condition of society in
which women are regarded as not in the least, _quâ_ women, inferior to
men.