Feminism in Greek Literature from Homer to Aristotle
Aristotle · en
Many estimates of women’s inferiority have ultimately an economic basis.
The more lucrative trades and professions are those for which it is
considered that women are temperamentally unfit.
It is a noticeable fact that all these general conceptions of women’s
weakness have always been closely connected with their legal status. In
Athens, where women could not hold property, and an heiress was taken
over by the nearest male relative as a necessary encumbrance on the
estate, the estimate of woman’s character was very low. In Alexandria
and at Rome, where women by various devices outwitted the law and became
possessed of some degree of economic independence, their moral position
also changed for the better. In England feminism begins with the Married
Women’s Property Act.
But as long as slavery, social or economic, is not recognised by the
law, it cannot be the curse that it was to ancient life. In Athens it
was a legal institution, owing its validity to much the same mode of
thought as made the wife also her husband’s chattel. It is the business
of lawyers to defend the law, and, if the law is bad, their moral sense
is necessarily warped in the process; so that it is not surprising if
the private speeches of the Attic orators, although they exhibit the
natural subtlety of the Athenians in a striking light, by no means
give an equally strong impression of moral rectitude. All the orators
are the same in this respect. Demosthenes in matters of State was a
high-minded patriot; as a lawyer he is, like the rest of his colleagues,
a professional liar, and does not scruple to falsify and misrepresent
the truth. Lysias so forgets the man in the advocate that he seems to
reserve his highest powers for his worst cases, and obviously delights
in such a client as the shameless old cripple for whom he writes his
most ingenious speech. Isæus has no regard for veracity, and it has been
found by painful experience that his unsupported statements, even on
simple questions of fact, are, to put it mildly, extremely unreliable. As
for Hyperides, he is careless of shame so long as he wins his case; and
his gesture, as he bids his fair client display her charms, is like the
calculated boldness of the slave-dealer offering his girls to the highest
bidder.
But if the orators give us an impression of cunning subtlety which far
transcends the bounds that we even now allow to lawyers, their clients
are in no better case. By the middle of the fourth century Athens was in
full decadence. Her men had lost all the vigour and courage that brought
their country safe through the dangers of the Persian Wars: her women,
perhaps, were even worse than the men—_corruptio optimi pessima_—and had
sunk into a state of utter degradation.