[Footnote 52: Professor Bosanquet translates _sinnliche_ here as "sensitive." I am inclined to think that Hegel here rather leaves out of sight the fact that in the process of Nature we have sensitive organic life no less than unconscious inorganic. His contrast is rather between the conscious life of man and unconscious nature, the conscious life that is not self-conscious being for the object of the contrast treated as equivalent to unconscious. He would also apparently ignore the fact that man himself and the higher beauty which attaches to him is also from ope point of view a part of the natural process.] [Footnote 53: That is, apart from purely personal ends in its pursuit, which are accidental to its essential notion.] [Footnote 54: That is, in the medium of conscious life.] [Footnote 55: _Einmal._ They are there, but they do not know they are there.] [Footnote 56: _Aus geistiger Bildung, i.e._, a high level of mental culture is necessary before the advent of civilized manners and customs in which spiritual life is reflected with real refinement and directness.] [Footnote 57: _Bedürfniss zur Kunst._] [Footnote 58: _Lit._, "In the form of the most abstract single subjectivity." That is to say, that the main fact about it is that it is felt; but, except in respect to intensity, it cannot be described as an object of thought with defining attributes, It is abstract individual sensation.] [Footnote 59: By the expression _Kreis_ Hegel would mean rather an indefinite sphere than a definite circle. The simile is perhaps not very apt. The idea, apparently, is of a sphere of feeling, that is, such as being self-complete, but is so abstract or indefinable that the introduction into it of positive ideas such as justice, etc., are the mere entrance of spectral forms which vanish in such an indefinable medium, without disclosing their nature. They are felt but not cognized for what they really are.] [Footnote 60: _Blinder_, blind in the sense that it is not guided by deliberate and self-conscious reason, _i.e._, mere animal instinct.]