The Philosophy of Fine Art, volume 4 (of 4): Hegel's Aesthetik
Georg Hegel · en
and human freshness of presentment, in virtue of which the gods appear
human and natural, is one of the pre-eminent qualities of the Homeric
poems. The divine figures of Virgil float before our vision as so many
invented wonders, as members of an artificial system. Virgil has not
wholly escaped the charge of mere travesty, despite his earnestness;
nay, this earnest mien of his is rather the cause of it, and Blumauer's
Mercury with his boots and spurs and riding-whip is not without its
justification. There is no necessity for any one else to make the
Homeric gods ridiculous. His own picture of them makes them quite
ridiculous enough. Nay, in his own story the gods themselves have their
laugh over the lame Hephestus, and over the cunning net in which Mars
lies in company with Venus, to say nothing of the box on the ear that
Venus gets, and the howl of Mars as he collapses. By means of these
touches of natural lustiness and gaiety the poet at once liberates
us from the external form which he set up, and enforces all the more
emphatically our common human nature, which he values, and which
suffers, however, the necessary and substantive power involved therein,
and the faith in the same, to remain. But one or two more examples of
similar detail. The tragic episode of Dido is so entirely to the modern
colour, that it was able to inspire a Tasso with emulation, nay, even
in part to a literal translation. Even nowadays the French are moved
to something like ecstasy over it. And yet how totally different in
their human naïveté, simplicity and truth are the Homeric narratives of
Circe and Calypso. The contrast is the same in Homer's account of the
descent of Odysseus into Hades. This obscure and twilight like retreat
of the shades is shown us through a dusky cloud, in an intermingling of
imagination and reality, which takes hold of us with astonishing force.
Homer does not suffer his hero to descend into any Underworld ready to
hand. Odysseus himself digs a pit, and pours therein the blood of a ram
he has killed; he summons the shades, which are then under constraint
to circle round him, and bids some of them drink fresh blood that they
may address him, and give him news, and drives away others with the
sword as they throng round him in their thirst for life. Everything
that happens here is bound up with the life of the hero, whose general
demeanour is the reverse of the humble attitude of Æneas and Dante. In
Virgil's account Æneas descends in the ordinary way; and the flight
of steps, Cerberus, Tantalus, and all the rest leaves us with the
impression of a definitely organized family establishment, quite to the
pattern of an orthodox compendium of mythology.