The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 01 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 01 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
8. To those that seek the cause of some certain and propounded
appearance or effect, it happens, sometimes, that they know not whether
the thing, whose cause is sought after, be matter or body, or some
accident of a body. For though in geometry, when the cause is sought of
magnitude, or proportion, or figure, it be certainly known that these
things, namely magnitude, proportion, and figure, are accidents; yet in
natural philosophy, where all questions are concerning the causes of the
phantasms of sensible things, it is not so easy to discern between the
things themselves, from which those phantasms proceed, and the
appearances of those things to the sense; which have deceived many,
especially when the phantasms have been made by light. For example, a
man that looks upon the sun, has a certain shining idea of the magnitude
of about a foot over, and this he calls the sun, though he know the sun
to be truly a great deal bigger; and, in like manner, the phantasm of
the same thing appears sometimes round, by being seen afar off, and
sometimes square, by being nearer. Whereupon it may well be doubted,
whether that phantasm be matter, or some body natural, or only some
accident of a body; in the examination of which doubt we may use this
method. The properties of matter and accidents already found out by us,
by the synthetical method, from their definitions, are to be compared
with the idea we have before us; and if it agree with the properties of
matter or body, then it is a body; otherwise it is an accident. Seeing,
therefore, matter cannot by any endeavour of ours be either made or
destroyed, or increased, or diminished, or moved out of its place,
whereas that idea appears, vanishes, is increased and diminished, and
moved hither and thither at pleasure; we may certainly conclude that it
is not a body, but an accident only. And this method is _synthetical_.
[Sidenote: The method of seeking whether any accident be in this or in
that subject.]