The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 06 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 06 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
_L._ So they are; for Sir Edward Coke produceth a record of one that was
drawn and hanged for taking the great seal from an expired patent, and
fastening it to a counterfeit commission to gather money. But he
approveth not the judgment, because it is the judgment for petty
treason: also, because the jury did not find him guilty of the offence
laid in the indictment, which was, the counterfeiting of the great seal,
but found the special matter, for which the offender was drawn and
hanged.
_P._ Seeing this crime of taking the great seal from one writing, and
fastening it to another, was not found high-treason by the jury, nor
could be found upon special matter to be the other kind of treason
mentioned in the same statute; what ground had either the jury to find
it treason, or the judge to pronounce sentence upon it?
_L._ I cannot tell. Sir Edward Coke seems to think it a false record;
for hereupon he saith, by way of admonition to the reader, that hereby
it appeareth how dangerous it is to report a case by the ear.
_P._ True; but he does not make it apparent that this case was untruly
reported; but on the contrary, confesseth that he had perused the same
record; and a man may, if it may be done without proof of the falsity,
make the same objection to any record whatsoever. For my part, seeing
this crime produced the same mischief that ariseth from counterfeiting,
I think it reason to understand it as within the statute; and for the
difference between the punishments, which are both of them capital, I
think it is not worthy to be stood upon; seeing death, which is _ultimum
supplicium_, is a satisfaction to the law, as Sir Edward Coke himself
hath in another place affirmed. But let us now proceed to other crimes.
_L._ Appendant to this is another crime, called misprision of treason;
which is the concealing of it by any man that knows it; and is called
misprision from the French _mespriser_, which signifies to contemn or
undervalue. For it is no small crime in any subject, so little to take
to heart a known danger to the King’s person, and consequently to the
whole kingdom, as not to discover not only what he knows, but also what
he suspecteth of the same, that the truth therefore may be examined. But
for such discovery, though the thing prove false, the discoverer shall
not, as I think, be taken for a false accuser; if for what he directly
affirms, he produce a reasonable proof, and some probability for his
suspicion. For else the concealment will seem justifiable by the
interest, which is to every man allowed, in the preservation of himself
from pain and damage.
_P._ This I consent to.
_L._ All other crimes merely temporal, are comprehended under felony or
trespass.