The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 06 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 06 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
And for the matter itself, it is manifest enough, that which we now call
murder, robbery, theft, and other practices of felons, are the same that
we call felony, and crimes in their own nature without the help of
statute. Nor is it the manner of punishment, that distinguisheth the
nature of one crime from another; but the mind of the offender and the
mischief he intendeth, considered together with the circumstances of
person, time, and place.
_L._ Of felonies, the greatest crime is murder.
_P._ And what is murder?
_L._ Murder is the killing of a man upon malice forethought, as by a
weapon, or by poison, or any way, if it be done upon antecedent
meditation; or thus, murder is the killing of a man in cold blood.
_P._ I think there is a good definition of murder set down by statute,
52 _Henry III, c. 25_, in these words: Murder, from henceforth, shall
not be judged before our justices, where it is found misfortune only,
but it shall take place in such as are slain by felony, and not
otherwise. And Sir Edward Coke interpreting this statute, 2 _Inst._ p.
148, saith, that the mischief before this statute was, that he that
killed a man by misfortune, as by doing any act that was not against
law, and yet against his intent the death of a man ensued, this was
adjudged murder. But I find no proof of that he allegeth, nor find I any
such law among the laws of the Saxons set forth by Mr. Lambard. For the
word, it is, as Sir Edward Coke noteth, old Saxon, and amongst them it
signified no more than a man slain in the field or other place, the
author of his death not known. And according hereunto, Bracton, who
lived in the time of Magna Charta, defineth it, fol. 134, thus: Murder
is the secret killing of a man, when none besides the killer and his
companions saw or knew it; so that it was not known who did it, nor
fresh suit could be made after the doer. Therefore, every such killing
was called murder, before it could be known whether it could be by
felony or not; for a man may be found dead that kills himself, or was
lawfully killed by another. This name of murder came to be the more
horrid, when it was secretly done, for that it made every man to
consider of their own danger, and him that saw the dead body, to boggle
at it, as a horse will do at a dead horse. And to prevent the same, they
had laws in force, to amerce the hundred where it was done, in a sum
defined by law to be the price of his life. For in those days, the lives
of all sorts of men were valued by money, and the value set down in
their written laws. And therefore Sir Edward Coke was mistaken, in that
he thought that killing a man by misfortune before the statute of
Marlebridge, was adjudged murder. And those secret murders were
abominated by the people, for that they were liable to so great a
pecuniary punishment for suffering the malefactor to escape. But this
grievance was by Canutus, when he reigned, soon eased. For he made a