The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
You should first have gotten into your minds the perfect and distinct
ideas of all the motions mentioned in this chapter, and then have
ventured upon the censure of them, but not before. And then you would
have seen that the body moved from A, describeth not the line A C, nor
the line A B, but a third, namely the semiparabolical line A H D.
Again, where I say, _Wherefore, if the whole A B be uniformly moved to C
D, in the same time wherein A C is moved uniformly to F G_; you ask me
“_whether with the same impetus or not?_” How is it possible that in the
same time two unequal lengths should be passed over the same impetus?
“_But why_,” say you, “_do you not tell us with what impetus A C comes
to F G?_” What need is there of that, when all men know that in uniform
motion and the same time, impetus is to impetus, as length to length?
Which to have expressed had not been pertinent to the demonstration.
That which follows in the demonstration, _rursus suppono quod latus A
C_, &c. to these words, _ut ostensum est_, _Art. 12_, you confute with
saying you have proved that article to be false. But you may see now, if
you please, at the same place that I have proved your objection to be
frivolous.
After this you run on without any argument against the rest of the
demonstration, showing nothing all the way, but that the variety and
concourse of motions, the speculations whereof you have not been used
to, have made you giddy.
To the nineteenth article you apply the same objection which you made to
the eighteenth. Which having been answered, it appears that from the
very beginning of your Elenchus to this place all your objections
(except such as are made to three or four mistakes of small importance
in setting down my mind), are mere paralogisms, and such are less
pardonable than any paralogism in Orontius, both because the subject as
less difficult is more easily mastered, and because the same faults are
most shamefully committed by a reprehender than by any other man.