The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11) — Thomas Hobbes — John Shaqi
The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 07 (of 11)
Thomas Hobbes · en
_A._ What I want of experiments you may supply out of your own store, or
such natural history as you know to be true; though I can be well
content with the knowledge of the causes of those things which everybody
sees commonly produced. Let us therefore now enquire the cause of some
effect particular.
_B._ We will begin with that which is the most universal, the universe;
and enquire in the first place, if any place be absolutely empty, that
is to say in the language of philosophers, whether there be any vacuum
in nature?
==========
CHAPTER III.
OF VACUUM.
_A._ It is hard to suppose, and harder to believe, that the infinite and
omnipotent Creator of all things should make a work so vast as is the
world we see, and not leave a few little spaces with nothing at all in
them; which put altogether in respect of the whole creation, would be
insensible.
_B._ Why say you that? Do you think any argument can be drawn from it to
prove there is vacuum?
_A._ Why not? For in so great an agitation of natural bodies, may not
some small parts of them be cast out, and leave the places empty from
whence they were thrown?
_B._ Because He that created them is not a fancy, but the most real
substance that is; who being infinite, there can be no place empty where
He is, nor full where He is not.
_A._ It is hard to answer this argument, because I do not remember that
there is any argument for the maintenance of vacuum in the writings of
divines: therefore I will quit that argument, and come to another. If
you take a glass vial with a narrow neck, and having sucked it, dip it
presently at the neck into a basin of water, you shall manifestly see
the water rise into the vial. Is not this a certain sign that you had
sucked out some of the air, and consequently that some part of the vial
was left empty?
_B._ No; for when I am about to suck, and have air in my mouth,
contracting my checks I drive the same against the air in the glass, and
thereby against every part of the sides of the hard glass. And this
gives to the air within an endeavour outward, by which, if it be
presently dipped into the water, it will penetrate and enter into it.
For air if it be pressed will enter into any fluid, much more into
water. Therefore there shall rise into the vial so much water as there
was air forced into the basin.
_A._ This I confess is possible, and not improbable.
_B._ If sucking would make vacuum, what would become of those women that
are nurses? Should they not be in a very few days exhausted, were it not
that either the air which is in the child’s mouth penetrateth the milk
as it descends, and passeth through it, or the breast is contracted?
_A._ From what experiment can you evidently infer that there is no
vacuum?