Bible-Burning: the substance of a sermon preached in St. Martin's Church, Birmingham, on Sunday evening, Dec. 10, 1848 — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Bible-Burning: the substance of a sermon preached in St. Martin's Church, Birmingham, on Sunday evening, Dec. 10, 1848
John Stuart Mill · en
But the Priest was provoked, forsooth, by the conduct of certain
Protestant Clergymen and their agents who enter the house of the poor
Romanist, to pervert his faith! The charge is that we are making
proselytes. If by this it be meant that we are trying to get people over
from one Church to another, I demur to it. It is my object, with God’s
assistance, to make them Christians, to draw them to Christ, but I wish
to make them _converts_ and not _proselytes_. I wish indeed to see them
Church of England Christians, because I believe that my own dear Church
exhibits Christ in her Articles and formularies, and is a truly
Scriptural Church. But I confess that I was almost provoked to a smile
when I read of _the complaints of Rome_ that we are seeking to
proselytise! Rome which is literally setting wife against husband,
daughter against father, by the most insidious artifices; perverting
Protestants, and even the children of Protestant Clergymen, by artifices
the most subtle! Rome which is not content with contesting the ground
with us in our own land but in heathen countries also, as well as in our
colonies! The charge of proselytising comes with a very bad grace from
the Church of Rome! Let me however say that though I do not wish to
_proselytize_ but to _convert_, I will not undertake to keep my Scripture
Readers out of any house at the dictation of Priest or Pope. I will not
undertake to leave men in error and darkness. Let us use lawful, open
handed, means, let us not have recourse to subtle artifice. Let us have
all as open as the day, and I have no fear for the ultimate progress of
the truth. And we ask all members of the Church of Rome to confine
themselves to honourable, straightforward, proceedings.
It will perhaps be said that in what I am now about to urge I am
trenching on party politics. I appeal to my two years’ ministrations in
this town, whether I have at any time been guilty of advancing anything
in the shape of party politics. But there are some questions in which
politics and religion are so intimately blended, that I hold it to be
false delicacy to abstain from the bold avowal of our sentiments. I put
it to you—are we prepared to pay money to the Romish Priests for burning
Bibles in Ireland or in England, without a manful, constitutional,
struggle? I know that if you deviate from the simple ground of
principle, and begin to talk of _expediency_, a strong case may readily
be made. On grounds of expediency, I myself should be disposed to yield,
but _as a sworn minister of the Church of England_, _I have proclaimed
Rome to be_ IDOLATROUS; _and if you are ashamed of your Church_, I AM
NOT; and I will not consent, either directly or indirectly, to support
idolatry—I will not consent to pay money for a Priest who goes into
London ’Prentice-street or into Ireland to burn the Word of God.