Bible-Burning: the substance of a sermon preached in St. Martin's Church, Birmingham, on Sunday evening, Dec. 10, 1848 — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Bible-Burning: the substance of a sermon preached in St. Martin's Church, Birmingham, on Sunday evening, Dec. 10, 1848
John Stuart Mill · en
Now with regard to the reply of the “Catholic Clergy” as they style
themselves, it admits the fact, namely, that a New Testament was burnt.
And in candour we are to take it for granted that the Priest expresses
his regret for having said he would burn other Bibles at any future time.
You will remark however, by the way, (though I shall not now dwell upon
it,) that there is not a word of regret for the utterance of the threat
of scurrilous and abusive language. Not one word is said in reference to
this point—that a man calling himself a minister, not of _a branch_ of
Christ’s Church, but of _the Catholic_ Church, tells a Protestant
Clergyman, in the precincts of his own parish, in the house of one of his
parishioners, that though he shall not advise any to resort to violence
against his person, he shall encourage them to use scurrilous and
insulting language towards him, if he attempts to pass the door.
But to return to the burning of the Testament.
Making every allowance for the members of a Church who regard the
Protestant version as erroneous, I am prepared to show you that this is
not a solitary instance of such proceedings in the Romish Church. And
therefore it is that, notwithstanding the public expression of regret now
read to you, I feel justified in dwelling upon this point. During the
past week I received a visit from a Protestant Clergyman from Ireland. I
was mentioning this incident to him, and he began to narrate to me one or
two other facts of a similar kind. I appeared interested in the subject,
and, without any solicitation on my part, yesterday morning, as I was
reading the apology of the Priests, the post brought me a letter from
this gentlemen, wherein he narrates the circumstance which occurred in
the parish of which he was once Curate. I should say, that I have the
names of place and persons in my hand and am quite prepared to give them
up if necessary. He says—
“When I was curate in the parish of —, diocese of Cork, my esteemed
rector the — established a scriptural school in the parish of — which
was attended by a considerable number of Roman Catholic children. A
Father — the parish priest, visited the house of a man named
Sullivan, whose daughter went to our school. Mr. — asked how the
little girl was improving, and said he wished to hear her read. She
brought him her Bible, which he no sooner saw than he made a rush at
her, snatched it out of her hand, called in the neighbours to warm
themselves by the light of a “Bible fire,” and then burned it, and
heaped the fire to make the blaze the brighter.”
If any person present wishes to see the names he is perfectly at liberty
to do so to-morrow morning at my house. I merely mention the
circumstance, to show that the Bible-burning in St. Peter’s district is
not a solitary instance.