Byzantine Constantinople, the walls of the city and adjoining historical sites — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Byzantine Constantinople, the walls of the city and adjoining historical sites
John Stuart Mill · en
Now, if the “seventy stadia” in this passage are to be understood in
the ordinary sense of the words, the route taken by the ships was
over eight English miles in length. But from no point between Top
Haneh and Beshiktash is the distance to the Golden Horn, across the
hills, so great. Hence the language of Leonard has been variously
interpreted, in the hope of bringing it into accord with what his
commentators deemed the real facts in the case. Dethier, in his
annotations to Zorzo Dolfin (_Siège de Constantinople_, No. xxii. p.
998), maintains that the numeral seventy gives the number of the
ships transported over the hills, and not the length of the road
tranversed: “Non sono 70 stadia, ma 70 galere o fuste.” Charles
Müller, the editor of Critobulus, referring to the statement of
Leonard, expresses the same opinion as Dethier, and thinks that the
number for the stadia has dropped out of the text of Leonard:
“Stadiorum numerus excedisse videtur, nam septuaginta vox ad navium
numerum, quem eundem etiam Chalcocondylas, p. 387, 8 præbet,
referenda est” (_Fragm. Hist. Græc._ p. 87). Another possible view
is that the number seventy is due to an error in the text. Or,
finally, it may be supposed that Leonard employed the term “stadium”
in a peculiar sense. One presumption in favour of this supposition
is the fact that elsewhere in his epistle, the measurements of
Leonard by stadia seem too gross mistakes to be made by such a man
as the archbishop, with the ordinary idea of a stadium in his mind.
The bridge, for example, which the Sultan built at Haskeui, to bring
his cannon closer to the Harbour Walls, and which Phrantzes (p. 252)
says was one hundred ortygia long, or one stadium, Leonard (p. 931)
represents as about thirty stadia in length, _i.e._, according to
the ordinary computation, between three and four miles in length,
where the harbour is not half a mile wide. Again, Leonard (p. 970)
speaks of the Turkish fleet as anchoring at a point less than one
hundred stadia from the shore of the Propontis: “Minus ad stadia
centum Propontidis ripa anchoras figunt”—a statement which, if it
refers to the distance of Beshiktash from the Seraglio Point, would
make that part of the Bosporus about ten miles broad! It should also
be added that Charles Müller thinks that the stadium of the later
Byzantine writers was one-third less than the Olympic stadium: “Adeo
ut stadium tertia parte minus quam vetus stadium Olympicum subesse
videri possit” (_Fragm. Hist. Græc._, v. p. 76). Du Cange
(_Glossarium Med. et Infim. Latinitatis_) says, respecting the use
of the term “stadium” by mediæval writers, “Mensuræ species, sed
ignota prorsus.”