“Someone will discover some day that Darwin’s conclusions were wrong,
that he left out some little near obvious thing with big results, and
his theory, which has worried thousands of people nearly to death, will
turn out to be one of those everlasting mannish explanations of
everything which explain nothing. I know what you are going to say; a
subsequent reversal of a doctrine does not invalidate scientific method.
I know. But these everlasting theories, and men are so ‘eminent’ and
important about them, are appalling; in medicine, it is simply
_appalling_, and people are just as ill as ever; and when they know
Darwin was mistaken, there will be an end of Herbert Spencer. There’s my
father, really an intelligent man, he has done scientific research
himself and knew Faraday, and he thinks First Principles the greatest
book that was ever written. I have argued and argued but he says he is
too old to change his cosmos. It makes me simply ill to think of him
living in a cosmos made by Herbert Spencer.”
“_Wait._ Excuse me but that is all too easy. In matter of science the
conclusions of Darwin will _never_ be displaced. It is as the alphabet
of biology, as Galilei is of Astronomy. More. These researches even need
not be made again. They are for all time verified. Herbert Spencer I
agree has carried too far in too wholesale a manner conclusions based on
Darwin’s discoveries; conclusions may lead to many inapplicable
theories, that is immaterial; but Darwin himself made no such theories.
There is no question of _opinion_ as to his discoveries; he supplies
simply unanswerable _facts_.”
“I think it’s Huxley who makes me angry with Darwinism. He didn’t find
it out, and he went swaggering about using it as a weapon; _frightfully_
conceited about it. That Thomas Henry Huxley should come off best in an
argument was quite as important to him as spreading the Darwinian
theory. I _never_ read anything like his accounts of his victories in
his letters.”
“That is most certainly not the spirit of Darwin, who was a most gentle
creature...... But you really surprise me in your attitude towards the
profession of law.”
“I don’t know anything whatever about laws; but I have met lawyers,
barristers and solicitors, and I think they are the most ignorant,
pig-headed people in the world. They have no minds at all. They don’t
affect _me_. But if I were ever before a judge I should shoot him. They
use cases to show off their silly wit, sitting thinking of puns; and
people are put to death.”