Femina, A Work for Every Woman — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Femina, A Work for Every Woman
John Stuart Mill · en
The credulous, and those who often may imagine that they require
medical advice, become the unconscious victims of the unhealthy
disproportion, for the doctor seizes the opportunity to make a case,
while the normal proportion of cases do not reach around. Thus, it
is calculated that at least fifty per cent. of all the diseases for
which patients are treated are fictitious as far as actual disease
is concerned, and the remaining fifty per cent. are, in the majority
of instances, overdosed and overdoctored. For this reason medical
legislation would not make a privileged class of physicians, nor
throw unusual safeguards around medical practitioners, but medical
legislation is to protect the people themselves from imposition and
quackery.
The reason for the overcrowded state of the profession is not alone
the laxity of medical laws, or the low standard of medical education
in most of our colleges, but the general tendency of the country
population to drift into the cities. Honest labor has not the dignity
which its importance demands, and a radically faulty method of
common-school education is another reason. Utilitarian manual methods,
in which the hands are educated for useful employment and the minds to
habits of industry, are to be wished for. Young men who have acquired a
technical education in mechanics and arts will learn to respect labor
in every department, and their ambition in life will be greater than to
swing a cane or wear a silk tile.
In proportion as the productive employments are made respectable, this
questionable ambition to become M. D.’s will fall off.
History tells us that the opulence of Rome was speedily accompanied by
a decline of its agriculture, after which came the fall of the Roman
Empire, because the country population became too indolent and restless
and flocked to the cities for an easier and luxurious living. History
in this respect seems to be repeating itself. We are always talking
of encouraging the beauty and growth of our cities, but not one word
of encouraging agriculture; no one talks of encouraging farm life
and making it profitable and attractive, so that men and women would
prefer the more independent subsistence in the country to a shabby
gentility in the city. Some reader may ask, What has all this to do
with doctoring? I say that the answer must already have been apparent;
it becomes the duty of everyone to interest himself, that the division
of labor shall be apportioned so as to do the greatest good to society.
We have a national characteristic which shows itself in an abnormal
conceit for everything American in a degree that is not essential
for true patriotism and love of country. But when by comparisons we
learn that there are abuses and errors which are destructive to a
healthy intellectual and material growth, we must have the honesty and
independence to acknowledge them, and busy ourselves to find a remedy
for existing evils.