Femina, A Work for Every Woman — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Femina, A Work for Every Woman
John Stuart Mill · en
What is ordinarily termed mind cure is not mind cure in the sense
that the term implies, but it is simply the mind toying or playing
with the idea of a cure, for while the mind is thus engaged, nature’s
energy is accomplishing the result or cure. This is the only rational
explanation, and corresponds with the cures that nature is continually
making in the lower orders of animals. If the recovery of the sick
depended entirely upon the caprice and wisdom of the doctor, and not
on the reparative forces of nature, the race would soon die out. I
fully recognize the fact that the curative force can be stimulated;
this may be done through the influence of nourishing food, alcoholic
stimulants, a drug or medicine, or through purely mental influences. No
physician can estimate how much merit he can accredit to the methods
or substances he employs in any particular case that recovers, and how
much to the lady physician, Dame Nature. This old lady doctor is ever
active, and the most inert drugs, employed or administered with her
assistance, have achieved wonderful cures; this the history of medicine
confirms. The tar water cure of Bishop Berkeley is an illustration
how an inert substance is capable of making for itself an enviable
reputation for curing ailments, like pleurisy, pneumonia, erysipelas,
asthma, indigestion, hypochondria, and other diseases. This remedy
had the vehement indorsement of one of the greatest metaphysicians of
the English-speaking world, and that the cures reported by him were
genuine no one will doubt for a moment; but the bishop, like many of
our day, was determined to have a remedy to cure disease, where none
was required, but the mind had to be humored, while nature was actively
repairing the disorder. To-day almost everyone is satisfied, that the
virtues ascribed to tar water by Berkeley were a delusion, which was
shared by all those who believed as he did.