It is above all things difficult to predict beforehand whether two
apparently antagonistic characters will really clash and jar in the
close union of married life, or whether, on the contrary, the
deficiencies of the one will be supplemented by those opposite
tendencies which are rather in excess in the other. It is notorious
that marriages are seldom perfect matches in the view of outsiders;
the incongruities in the temperaments and the habits of life and
thought, are more easily discerned than the fusing influence of ardent
love can be measured. Nor, indeed, can the changes which will be
worked in the disposition by a surrender to the free play of emotion
be accurately foreseen. Considerations such as these, however, do not
have much weight in the mind of a young man whose experience of the
mysteries of the human heart is yet to come; and James Martineau was
strongly averse to the engagement of his sister and his friend. Their
attachment was not then permitted to become an engagement. Worthington
was poor--was still only a student--Harriet was supposed, at that
time, to be well portioned; the sensitive temperament of the young
lover felt the variety of discouragements placed in the path of his
affection, and so that affection which should have brought only joy
became, in fact, to Harriet the cause of sorrow, suspense and anxiety.
Yet its vivifying influence was felt, and the true happiness which is
inseparable from mutual love, however the emotion be checked and
denied its full expression, was not lacking. For some insight into
what Harriet Martineau knew and felt of love, we must look elsewhere
than in the formal record of the Autobiography.[3] But this, like all
the other chief events of her life, has found a place in her works
under a thin veiling of her personality. Let us see from one of her
early essays how Harriet Martineau learned to regard love. The essay
is called "In a Hermit's Cave."
[3] Mr. H. G. Atkinson writes to me: "She had written much
more at length (than is published) in her Autobiography about
her courtship; but she consulted me about publishing it, and
I advised her not to do so--the matter counted for so little
in such a life as hers." The quotation which I give here
shows for what it did really count in the history of her
mental development. But so difficult must it needs be for the
writer of an autobiography to speak frankly of the more
sacred experiences of the life, that it is not surprising
that Harriet Martineau "destroyed what she had written," when
so advised by the friend whom she consulted. I need only add
that the many new details about the facts of this matter,
which I am able to give, I have received from two of her own
generation, both of whom were very intimate friends of hers
at the time when all this occurred.