Lancaster's Choice — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Lancaster's Choice
John Stuart Mill · en
"But it was not a joke, really," he said, embarrassed. "You know what
Tennyson says about a 'lie that is half a truth,' Lady Adela. Well,
that is how the case stands. Lady Lancaster has simply misrepresented
the facts. There was a grain of truth in her bushel of falsehood."
"Oh, dear!" cried Lady Adela, in dismay. She nestled a little nearer
him on the fauteuil where they were sitting. "Do tell me the right of
it, Lord Lancaster; I am all curiosity."
"Then I will tell you the right of it, if you care to hear," he
replied; and there was so stern a look on his face that the earl's
daughter was frightened. She wondered if he was angry with her.
"I hope you are not offended with me for repeating what Lady Lancaster
said," she observed sweetly, giving him a demure look out of her large
black eyes.
He looked at her gravely a minute without replying. She was very
handsome, certainly--a brilliant brunette, very vivacious when it
pleased her to be so, and again with a languor and indolence amounting
to laziness. She had been in society several seasons, and owned to
twenty-three years old. She was beautiful, graceful, and dignified, and
Lancaster felt that she would make a fitting mistress for Lancaster
Park; but his pulse did not beat any faster at her bright glance, nor
at her sweet, half-confidential tones.
But he looked back at her reassuringly as he replied:
"I am sorry I looked so black as to inspire you with such an idea, Lady
Adela. Of course I am not offended with you. You are not answerable for
Lady Lancaster's peccadilloes. I think, however, that she might have
shown more respect to Lieutenant De Vere than to indulge herself in
such gossip, more than half of it being false."
"Oh, then he isn't going to commit such a folly after all?" she
exclaimed, relieved that it was not so, for her patrician pride had
been somewhat hurt at the idea of one of her own order descending to a
plebeian.
"You jump so quickly from one conclusion to another, Lady Adela, that
you will not give me time to explain," he said, smiling.
"Oh!" she cried, abashed. "Then I shall not say another word, only
listen to your story."
"There is no story--only an explanation," he said. "I should not speak
of it, only I think De Vere would thank me for setting him right. Yes,
he is in love, Lady Adela, but not with a servant girl, as my aunt
insinuated. The young lady who has won his heart is a fair, refined
young girl, cultured and accomplished, and of respectable although not
noble birth. She is an American girl who came over with De Vere and
myself from New York to her aunt, who is the housekeeper here. That is
the long and the short of the servant-girl story."
"You know her?" cried Lady Adela, amazed. "Oh, how I would like to see
this fascinating girl, admired both by Lieutenant De Vere and Lord
Lancaster!"
"You have seen her," he replied, with that quick flush that showed so
clearly through his fine skin.
"Where?" she cried, amazed.