Leigh Hunt's Relations with Byron, Shelley and Keats — John Stuart Mill — John Shaqi
Leigh Hunt's Relations with Byron, Shelley and Keats
John Stuart Mill · en
Such a dual attitude in Keats can be explained only by a dual feeling in
his mind, for it is impossible to believe him capable of deliberate
deceit. He may have realized Hunt's affectation and superficiality and
"disgusting taste"; he was probably swayed by Haydon to distrust Hunt's
morals; the suspicions planted by Haydon concerning _Endymion_ rankled;
but at the same time Hunt's charm of personality, and the assistance and
encouragement given in the first days of their friendship, formed a bond
difficult to break. Of Leigh Hunt's attitude there can be no doubt, for
through his long life of more than threescore years and ten, filled with
many friendships of many kinds, he can in no instance be charged with
insincerity. There is no conclusive proof on record to show him deserving
of the insinuations which Keats believed in respect to _Endymion_, for
Haydon is not trustworthy, and the opinion of a lady given through Haydon
may be dismissed on the same grounds.[131] Reynolds' testimony is not
damaging in itself, and in the absence of facts to the contrary may have
been wrongly construed by Keats. To the charges against himself, Leigh
Hunt has replied in the following passage, "affecting and persuasive in
its unrestrained pathos of remonstrance":[132]
"an irritable morbidity appears even to have driven his suspicions to
excess; and this not only with regard to the acquaintance whom he
might reasonably suppose to have had some advantages over him, but to
myself, who had none; for I learned the other day, with extreme pain,
such as I am sure so kind and reflecting a man as Mr. Monckton Milnes
would not have inflicted on me could he have foreseen it, that Keats
at one period of his intercourse suspected Shelley and myself of a
wish to see him undervalued! Such are the tricks which constant
infelicity can play with the most noble natures. For Shelley, let
_Adonais_ answer. For myself, let every word answer which I uttered
about him, living and dead, and such as I now proceed to repeat. I
might as well have been told that I wished to see the flowers or the
stars undervalued, or my own heart that loved him."[133]
Hunt's feeling towards Keats is nowhere better expressed than in his
_Autobiography_: "I could not love him as deeply as I did Shelley. That
was impossible. But my affection was only second to the one which I
entertained for that heart of hearts."[134]
Keats's atonement is contained in the last letter that he ever wrote: "If
I recover, I will do all in my power to correct the mistakes made during
sickness, and if I should not, all my faults will be forgiven."[135]